User Avatar
sjlutgen
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Tuesday, Apr 01 2025

#feedback Question 1 could be confusing to some. The fact that some mammals lack limbs does not technically negate the first statement that all non-water-breathing mammals have limbs. The mammals without limbs could all breathe water, allowing the first statement to remain true. The first statement does not establish whether or not water-breathing mammals exist. It requires outside knowledge that no mammals actually breathe water, which is a common misconception about marine mammals. Right now, Q1 is logically equivalent to: All Claussen's pickles are kosher is negated by some pickles are not kosher. For the second statement to negate the first, it must be established that Claussen's are the only pickles to exist.

1
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Tuesday, Apr 01 2025

Dolphins don't breathe water—no mammals do. They do not have gills. Dolphins have to surface to breathe every few minutes. They have lungs and hold their breath when underwater.

0
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Monday, Mar 24 2025

There will be a blackout, unless the heatwave abates. This is saying that if the heatwave continues, there will be a blackout.

If the heat wave does not abate, then it will cause a blackout.

If no blackout occurs, then the heat wave must have abated. Otherwise, the heat wave would have caused a blackout.

If the heat wave abates, there are still other threats that could cause a blackout, such as unrelated equipment failure.

2
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Thursday, Mar 20 2025

Couldn't each of these hypotheses be contributing to the observed phenomenon? Thus, both are potential links in the causal chain. They're not necessarily mutually exclusive and therefore not necessarily competing. Toxic runoff and algal bloom could both be contributing to dolphin deaths.

0
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Thursday, Mar 20 2025

Some heavily implies more than one. I don't know a single context where you'd use "some" to describe only 1 of something.

3
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Monday, Jan 27 2025

That's a great way of putting it!

0
User Avatar
sjlutgen
Friday, Jan 17 2025

The sentence isn't about the leaders, it's about how their attempts will backfire. Everything else is modifying that core concept of the sentence.

3

Confirm action

Are you sure?