Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!

"but" indicator

Arete_SouthbayArete_Southbay Live Member
in General 359 karma

Is "but" a premise or conclusion indicator?

Comments

  • hopefullinghopefulling Member
    edited November 2020 905 karma

    It's neither.

    It's a 'counter-premise' indicator, meaning that it introduces something that brings up a point of opposition. (an adversative)

    In the CC, we are introduced to the concept of 'although, but, and however', which divide the stimulus into the 'context' (the stuff proceeding it) from the 'main argument' (the stuff after it - either the author's argument or in a hybrid argument someone else's argument).

  • edited November 2020 1952 karma

    but/however/yet - these are pivot words after which, at times, the author chimes in.
    at other times, they can be used as a counter-premise.

    so i wouldn't always take it as a premise/conclusion indicator; in my opinion, it becomes pretty dangerous when you approach the lsat in a formulaic way.

    example:
    i scored a 180 on the lsat. but i should clarify: that was from an open-book pt i did.
    therefore, i don't know if i'll get into yale with that score.

Sign In or Register to comment.