Both Agree Question Type Inquiry

damaga0728

Will there ever be answer choice where both authors disagree with it and that would be considered that they both agree (to disagree) answer?
(Example: LSAT 80, Logical Reasoning I, Q18)
This is a both agree question, however, I was wondering if there could be a scenario where both of them disagree on an answer choice (and that would be considered an agree to disagree)? Feel like there’s a simple explanation for this but I was thinking about it.

alexaleknaz

I doubt that would be a likely scenario, but if a question like that did come up, you would most likely approach it as an Agree question with the correct answer being the negation of whatever it is both affirm to disagree on. Example:

"Alice: I believe beavers' teeth are physically not capable of cutting down metal.
Bob: Forget beaver teeth, they wouldn't even be able to grip the metal to then cut it!

Alice and Bob are most likely to agree on which of the following?
[correct answer] Some physical trait of beavers does not readily enable them to cut metal."