One quick note that might help you is that I often find myself falling for answer choices that are sufficient (but not necessary) for necessaryassumption questions. They are really attractive! So I try to be on guard against them.
... 'easier' questions, the assumption you need to make in ... that often function as sufficient assumptions (PT 54 S2 ... weak argument. Supplying a necessaryassumption plugs up a potential ... strengthening, or providing a necessaryassumption, simply makes it less ...
In assumption questions, most of the ... sky is overcast." The sufficientassumption is "It has always ... then the conclusion follows. Necessaryassumption will be "It has sometimes ... conclusion will not follow. Sufficientassumption gives us certainty about what ...
... of the conclusion
6. SufficientAssumption Questions
- You are ... 7. Pseudo-sufficientAssumption Questions:
- Very similar to sufficientassumption questions in that ... a similar flaw
16. NecessaryAssumption Questions
- A valid ...
... conclusion is both a necessary and a sufficientassumption for itself. So if ... question that asks for a necessary or sufficientassumption of the CONCLUSION, then ... work. Drilling a bunch of necessaryassumption questions should help illuminate exactly ...
... for a flaw/strengthen/weaken/necessary or sufficientassumption/ question. We're being ... to be on, say, a necessaryassumption question). The scenario the argument ...
... this sufficientassumption (that “trees grow 1 ring per year”) a necessaryassumption? Well ... year” is a sufficientassumption, it’s not a necessaryassumption. Given the additional ...
... the type of assumption question. If it's a sufficientassumption question, you ... argument air tight. In a necessaryassumption question, the answer choice will ...
... 4-6 points on assumption questions; after getting ... between a necessary and a sufficientassumption and tools ... that I can use to help me with necessary ... assumptions. Since reviewing them, I rarely miss assumption ...
Good thread! I was just wondering the same . Thank god to Sage at least now I know there is a difference between sufficient and necessaryassumption questions (didn't learn that in my over 1,000$ crappy test prep course).
... recognize that there's some sufficient and necessaryassumption confusion because there's ... "treats a sufficientassumption as a necessaryassumption" and "treats a necessaryassumption as a sufficientassumption."
... or how little.
-For sufficientassumption, you need to figure out ... be sufficient to guarantee that the argument would work.
-For necessaryassumption ...
... have a feel for the assumption that the argument is making ... on main point questions and sufficient/necessaryassumption questions. The other questions use ...
... seem more like a necessaryassumption rather than a sufficientassumption? After reading your ... think it really is a sufficientassumption. In order for it to ... be sufficient, don't you need to ...
... you are giving is a SufficientAssumption. With the two premises, (one ... .
It's not a Necessaryassumption because, while the negation does ... much caffeine" limit.
A necessaryassumption always destroys the argument when ...
@Elle2015 If this were a necessaryassumption question, then I think you’d be on to something, employing the negation test. But this is a sufficientassumption question. So we need an answer that will make the argument valid.
... think answer D is a necessaryassumption due to the strength of ... of craters. Therefore, D is necessary because if you negate it ... sure that answer D is sufficient, though. Geophysics is the study ...
... and can pick tiny little necessary assumptions that don't ... to be important to be necessary.
It doesn't ... and yet it's a necessaryassumption. If the opposite is true ... a Sufficientassumption, and guarantees the conclusion, but it's not necessary. Even ...
... of knowledge. Michiko adds the sufficient condition that “if they know ... sufficientassumption and conclude with the correctly corresponding necessaryassumption. So to trigger the sufficientassumption ...
... means. Of course, denying a Necessaryassumption absolutely devastates an argument. And ... option to negate a stated NecessaryAssumption. That would be the equivalent ... that “unless" means to "negate sufficient" all day long, but if ...
... the assumption true), Strengthen (make the assumption true), Necessaryassumption (identify the one assumption who ... 's negation would destroy the argument), Sufficientassumption ...