- Joined
- Apr 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
The key phrase that makes AC E correct is "a significant amount."A significant amount of old homes having >3 apartments could still amount to more apartments than most old homes having >1 apartments.
It's a tricky question that's worded badly on purpose, but the logic is still sound.
AC C links the behavior of both humans and chimps to their biology, the genetic predisposition. It basically builds the bridge between the argument and the premises needed to support it.
Got this right but took too much time on it. AC C does not address the findings that scientists are citing less varied articles even though increased journal access has made it easier. I'm trying to think about why I almost chose it and honestly can't, because it has nothing to do with the stimulus. E makes much more sense, and I think it's mostly because of the "most highly regarded" phrase. Highly regarded not only serves as a possible explanation that it's highly regarded by fellow scientists, but also by other large communities. And when doing a research paper for example, one typically aims to cite sources that are peer reviewed and have proven professionals as contributors.
One thing I'm learning about weaken and necessary assumption questions is that most of the time, proving the possibility of a situation is enough. I originally narrowed it down to ACs B and C, and chose C because the "not for others" phrase in B initially turned me off. However, we don't have to assume that ProBit was one of the computer brands where most service requests are sent to manufacturers; just knowing that ProBit being one of them is possible, is enough to weaken the argument. I'm seeing these possibility scenarios more in the modern LSATs, whereas older ones were more definitive in their ACs.
Also, just another consideration, the argument states that "ProBit is the more reliable personal computer brand." And AC C discusses only one company. To prove such a claim, wouldn't one company be too small of a sample size? Maybe I'm thinking too hard about it, but AC B is also more attractive in this respect because it expands its scope to multiple computer brands, which is a better metric to determine reliability of a PC brand.
While AC B does indicate a change in tone and an incoming conclusion, it's merely setting up the actual conclusion. This is evidenced by the lack of support and premises for the statement, while AC C continues on with premises for support.
AC E is a lot stronger than AC D. AC D makes an assumption that the efforts of bird lovers to preserve habitats is making a difference in the ability of wild birds to survive. These efforts could just be half-hearted attempts, or they could even be extremely dedicated to the cause but still not producing results. AC E is correct because the key word is "must;" wild birds must depend on humans to survive; there's no ifs, ands or buts. It also creates a necessary condition; without the aid of humans in this example, wild birds cannot survive.
C has little to do with the conclusion. Educational purposes are not even mentioned in the passage. We need a rule that states if no evidence for accuracy ---> cannot be considered historically accurate, which E explicitly states.
One thing I tend to forget when doing if true questions vs. if valid questions: if true allows for extraneous events that can support the argument, while if valid must strictly be within the given premises. We don't know if people watch dramas for educational purposes. E is completely valid because it doesn't assume anything more than what the passage provides.
Menkin starts by saying "If your principle is correct..." This should already give the answer as to what the disagreement will be about, because they are engaging in a hypothetical to try to undermine Hendry's argument. The rest of the passage basically serves as a time sink.
B does not address the author's conclusion like C does, which is basically implying that less people = less demographic accuracy.
Ok, so I've been staring at this passage for about 10 minutes and the video explanation didn't help me too much...I finally reread the question stem closely and I think I know what went wrong. The question stem is asking us to strengthen the argument's conclusion, not the argument itself. This is tricky, because in almost every other strengthen question, we're asked to strengthen the argument, meaning to justify the premises. In this question, almost everything besides the conclusion is...irrelevant? Because we just need to prove the conclusion, that's it. And C basically restates the conclusion, so it's correct.
I'm not saying that D doesn't make sense as to why it's wrong, or that J.Y.'s explanation is confusing. Rather, what I'm saying is that it doesn't even matter, because we are not focused on justifying the premises. So, if you read and understood what the question stem is asking, you don't even need to know why D is wrong to know that it's wrong. Any time spent trying to even consider its logic is wasted, because it has nothing to do with strengthening the conclusion.
Anyhow, as with most of the questions that I've gotten incorrect, the lesson is to read more slowly.
First time in a while that I got a level 1 question wrong. I overanalyzed this question because I'm used to doing so for the more difficult ones. While I could make a case for C being right, B is much stronger because it addresses the reason for turning off the air conditioner. I got confused by the "below normal levels" too, because I didn't think you could assume that the fuel economy was at normal levels before going up the steep hill. But the passage says the fuel economy dropped "considerably" when going up the hill, so I think the passage had already made that assumption.
It's more difficult than others, but it's not a "bad" question. People need to remember that weakening does not always mean vaporizing someone else's argument to where they will never have another rebuttal. It simply means to weaken, whether by a lot or a little. The argument is that because Jason shops at Kelly's Grocery, it must be false that his restaurant's food contains no chemical pesticides. We're not trying to prove that his food indeed contains no pesticides though; we're trying to prove that it could be possible for him to shop at Kelly's and still be true to his claim. AC C gives us that; whether or not he's shopping in the sections without chemical pesticides does not matter. What matters is that there are sections without pesticides that he could shop at.
B makes sense. In this question; temperature is a constant: Town T is always at least ten degrees colder than Town C. So, it never matters what time of day it is.
I understand, and I'm disappointed in myself for the reason why I didn't choose B. I thought, "well that's absurd, there could be many other reasons why Plastonica moved to the area." There probably are. Maybe Plastonica's CEO was in such crazy love with his long-distance girlfriend in this area that he moved his whole entire business there just to be close to her. Not plausible, but still possible. However! It's not about finding the flaw, it's about justifying the author's reasoning. Plastonica had to have moved for the incentives alone in order for the author's argument to make sense, that the tax bill has created jobs in the area.
Got this wrong. I knew that the author had attacked the sources making the argument and called them basically hypocrites, instead of attacking the argument itself. But I looked for something along these lines and got confused when I didn't see it. However, D pretty much says the flaw in a vague way. In other questions where sources are attacked, I noticed that the AC sometimes says what D says, that no justification was given to choose their argument. I will (hopefully) not make this mistake again!
I was really confused about this question under timed conditions. I don't think it was because of the content itself, but more-so the question stem. "Most strongly rejected" is a better way to reword what we're supposed to look for; basically looking for something that could be possible, but also within the realm of what the question has provided us. The other four answer choices require us to make far more outlandish assumptions than D does, which is more tame in comparison.
D is not as "airtight" as most other LR answer choices. Yes, you could say he was whispering, or maybe he kept saying "whoah" and his companion needed more information. But he didn't have to do those things! He could have read it to himself, and his companion would have still pressed for more information; it's entirely possible. When I think of it like this, the answer makes way more sense.
I think what the question is implying is that there's only one general assembly. "The" is the key word, not "a" (general assembly). I didn't pick up on this and believed there could be two, with each possibly being an hour or less. Once I realized this, the answer is incredibly obvious. I think the video explanation of this question confused me more.
Got this right only through process of elimination. It didn't occur to me that "worst review" could mean either poorly written or most condemning. It's worth taking a step back and stop over analyzing phrases sometimes.
I put A, but it makes sense why I got it wrong. One thing I need to remember about weakening questions is that even if an AC weakens an argument by a tiny bit, it's still the correct answer. Sometimes, that tiny bit is so hard to detect even though it may be obvious, so process of elimination is key.
I originally was stuck between D and A, and chose D. My line of reasoning for not choosing A was, "what if there are other plants that provide the same toxin, but the grass is the most abundant, or most beneficial to the caterpillars?" I realized I had made the mistake of assuming more than what the argument provided. Even after taking many PT's and doing pretty good, I'm still making the occasional rookie mistake. Just goes to show how important it is to remember the fundamentals.
I originally narrowed it down to A and B. I didn't realize that precipitation was referring to both rain and snow, so if there is an increased amount of snow instead of rain then it defeats the argument. This is a good question. Just goes to show how one or two words misinterpreted can really mess you up.
How are they dumb? Truly national, in the context of this passage, can very validly mean both diversity and spreading throughout the country.