- Joined
- Jan 2026
- Subscription
- Core
Admissions profile
Discussions
i got rid of c because i didn't know if it was correct to label it as a "recent" development. i never know when i am being too nit piki with the answers.
i think reading this sentence 'Research shows that the major leg muscles of people walking in toning shoes receive no more exercise than those of people walking in ordinary walking shoes.'
is what tripped a lot of people out. it is not saying that each group receives equal (possibly less) amount of exercise. is it saying the major leg muscle itself receives equal (possibly less) amount of exercise, where you are wearing the toning shoe or not. it has nothing to do with the total length of time one exercises.
i think if you read the above sentence in this way it helps you see it better:
"While they're walking, the toning shoes don't give their major leg muscles any extra workout compared with regular shoes"
when i finally pick an answer thinking i was so fast and i check to see im still 28 seconds over the target time...
@Cpierce i know this was from a year ago lol but i am responding anyway. consider this analogous argument to understand it better:
"driving while under the influence is a factor that can cause you to get into an accident."
"yeah well driving while texting can cause you to get into an accident."
is that really weakening the claim that driving under the influence cannot cause you to get into an accident. no. you would simply reply with, "i know but i am talking about driving under the influence. "
my tactic for this under timed conditions was "new idea in conclusion" it needs to be in the AC.
i am someone who relies on the negation test when it comes to necessary assumption questions, so this is how i negated them:
all of these AC are the negated version:
a) last year, some people in the editorialist's country who claimed in polls to be tired of television news programs' obsession with celebrity scandals also claimed to be unwilling to watch such programs.
this negated version does not hurt the argument.
b) last year, 49% in the editorialist's country who claimed in polls to be tired of television news programs' obsession with celebrity scandals and to be unwilling to watch such program continued to watch those programs.
(almost everyone = most, when negating the quantifier most = 49%)
when negated this does not hurt the argument. the argument does not need almost everyone nor does it need everyone.
c) last year, no people who responded to polls in the editorialist's country did not believe that in their responses they were portraying themselves as they actually were.
DOUBLE NEGATION:
last year, everyone who responded to polls in the editorialist's country did believe that in their responses they were portraying themselves as they actually were.
even if they did believe this, the stim already takes care of this by saying "whether or not they are aware of it", so whether they believe it or not this is not hurting the argument.
d) last year, some of the people in the editorialist's country who responded to polls about their views about television news programs portrayed themselves as they actually were.
e) last year, no people responding to polls in the editorials's country wished to be perceived as unwilling to watch television news programs.
if this is the case then the negated version of e completely ruins the support structure of the stimulus.
please let me know if there are any mistakes with my line of thinking
@monmon i believe so. in pt 126, s4, q5, i feel as tho the answer is getting at the idea that the medical specialists specially give tailored medical insight to specific people who have specific problems. I feel like with this question it plays a long the same line. Essentially insinuating that physical therapy patients are directed to specific areas (GP or specialist) depending on what they need more attention to. this is what i understood.
@divenadonthi651 i actually laughed out reading this. couldn't agree more
i know this comment was from years ago but maybe it will be helpful for the next person lol.
this is the logical process i used: the idea behind this problem is that people who work outside the home spend less total time preparing dinner, but their dinners are still just as nutritional, varied, and substantial as the dinners of people who don't work outside the home. well that doesn't make sense...how can they spend less time preparing dinner but still produce dinners that are equally good?
when looking at AC D: because people who work outside the home eat dinner at home 20% less often, if they eat at home less often, they have fewer dinners to prepare (less minutes spent preparing food). so overall, they can spend less time preparing dinner each week, while the dinners they do prepare can still be just as nutritious and varied.
i think if you read this question like an NA it helps you understand it better: If less fish are being caught, and the stim is suggesting that the price will increase and as a result, consumers will be hurt by this - it is essentially implying that there will be a high demand for a product that has low supply. lots of people want the fish (less fishing = less supply).
to justify the claim that consumers will be hurt by this action, it is assuming that the demand will still be high. if you were to negate this AC and say the demand for halibut will decrease substantially after the new restrictions are imposed, well then the claim is not justified. because they could merely state "how will consumers be hurt, there will no longer be a high demand for the fish".
just a tip for anyone, while this doesn't work for every SA, it is still a worthy tool to help you eliminate answers (in this case it was the only AC that had the concept). The only time we talk about best consequences is in the conclusion and it is mentioned no where else. we know we need to link that idea to our premise somehow therefore any AC with it will need this concept.
this lazy girl hack does not work a lot of the time nevertheless it is still a valuable tool that might come in handy.