User Avatar
yade
Joined
Jun 2026
Subscription
Core

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided Goal score: 180
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
2028

Discussions

User Avatar
yade
Friday, Aug 21

ok what. im gonna have a BF. no, I'm gonna write a letter

1
User Avatar
yade
Wednesday, Aug 12

I'm worried my reasoning for eliminating E is wrong, but I'm not sure, even after watching the explanation...

I eliminated E because the subject in the answer choice is similar DNA. However, the stimulus only tells us that the DNA found (used to support the conclusion that there was no interbreeding) indicated significant DNA differences.

I tried the negation test with (E), which gives: "similarities in the DNA of two species is not the result of interbreeding."

I concluded from this (and this is where I'm not sure I did it right) that (E) is not necessary to the argument because it has no bearing on the arguments conclusion, given the conclusion relies only on differences in the DNA comparison being significant, not similarities in the DNA comparison being insignificant.

Did anyone else think this?

2
User Avatar
yade
Tuesday, Aug 4

if (B) had said "most new products fail whether or not they are supported by marketing campaigns" would it be the correct answer/succeed in weakening the argument at least a little, or is the language still too weak.

(new products -most-> fail regardless of new campaign)

In other words (if above were the case), could we ever reasonably assume our product (being a new product) is at risk of failing since most fail, or would it have to say "all" in order to pertain to our product and therefore do something to the original argument, changing it from only a chance of success to no chance of success?

1
User Avatar
yade
Monday, Aug 3

@ratman23

I almost missed the point of A, but this helped me out so I hope it helps you

At the end of the stimulus, it gives us one last reason to avoid irradiated foods. To try to add support this argument, it says : Third, irradiation spawns unique radiolytic products that cause serious health problems, including cancer.

In other words it's saying DO NOT eat irradiated foods. why not??? because irradiation creates (spawns) little weird evil things (unique radiolytic products) that are proven to cause serious health problems, including CANCER.

After reading this, we assume the little evil cancer causing things stick onto our food after irradiation. Answer choice A says no.

A: Unique radiolytic products have seldom been found in any irradiated food.

A says: "ok sure maybe its true irradiation creates little evil things that cause cancer, but it doesn't get stuck on food... in fact, No one has ever actually found unique radiolytic products IN the irradiated food"

This weakens the original argument by destroying that third premise that tried to scare us out of eating irradiated foods

1
User Avatar
yade
Wednesday, Jul 8

does anyone know if its possible/how to print these examples to keep a wrong answers diary ?

1
User Avatar
yade
Friday, Jun 12

@TankeySilk

Mickey argument :

the premises in the mickey argument claim that Walt has a pass, that there are ONLY two ways to get a pass (1st way OR 2nd way) and that Walt did not receive his pass the 1st way. If we assume all those premises (claims) are true, then the conclusion that Walt received his pass the 2nd way is true.

strong argument, conclusion is well supported by the premises

Trash bin argument : less strong, not certain because the premises don’t guarantee the conclusion is true.

The premises claim the bin is toppled, the cat is on the counter and that the cat likely ate from the bin (because of his expression). The conclusion is that Mr. Fat Cat knocked over the trash in order to eat it. This is still an argument but it isn’t very strong because even if we assume all the premises are true it doesn’t guarantee the conclusion. Based on those claims it’s not guaranteed that the cat did it, or that it was intentional, just that he was there. (He could have found it already spilt, knocked it over by accident, knocked it over without knowing there was food in it, etc.)

2

Confirm action

Are you sure?