A Game A Day
… keeps the, um, mental atrophy away? :-P
I’m on the verge of completing my Sequencing Games training, and because I
have no life am super ultra cool, I made up my own logic game. Take that, LSAC!
I would be so flattered if you will solve this. I think it’s pretty easy (LOL creator bias? It’s nice being on this end), so maybe 5-6ish minutes to solve? Actually, I have no idea.
And now, tongue firmly in cheek, I present to you the following game:
Having scored 175+ on their LSATs, seven smart cookies –
@amanda_kw,
@blah170blah,
@christopherblair,
@DumbHollywoodActor,
@emli1000,
@"Fritz A W", and
@nicole.hopkins – were hired by 7Sage to be online tutors for select new members. There is one tutor for each day of the week (running from Monday to Sunday), and each tutor is assigned exactly once. Dillon A. Wright must create a schedule according to the following conditions:
Blah170blah can only tutor on Saturday or Sunday.
Amanda_kw and Emli1000 must tutor before Nicole.hopkins does.
Fritz A W must tutor the day after Nicole.hopkins.
Christopherblair tutors before Emli1000.
Dillon carefully crafted a schedule according to everyone’s stipulations and availabilities, only to be grilled by JY and Alan with the following questions:
1. Which one of the following could be a possible tutoring schedule?
(A) Monday: DumbHollywoodActor; Tuesday: Christopherblair; Wednesday: Amanda_kw; Thursday: Emli1000; Friday: Nicole.hopkins; Saturday: Fritz A W; Sunday: Blah170blah
(B) Monday: DumbHollywoodActor; Tuesday: Fritz A W; Wednesday: Amanda_kw; Thursday: Emli1000; Friday: Christopherblair; Saturday: Nicole.hopkins; Sunday: Blah170blah
(C) Monday: Emli1000; Tuesday: Christopherblair; Wednesday: Amanda_kw; Thursday: Nicole.hopkins; Friday: Fritz A W; Saturday: DumbHollywoodActor; Sunday: Blah170blah
(D) Monday: Amanda_kw; Tuesday: Emli1000; Wednesday: Christopherblair; Thursday: Nicole.hopkins; Friday: Fritz A W; Saturday: DumbHollywoodActor; Sunday: Blah170blah
(E) Monday: Amanda_kw; Tuesday: Christopherblair; Wednesday: Emli1000; Thursday: Blah170blah; Friday: Nicole.hopkins; Saturday: Fritz A W; Sunday: DumbhollywoodActor
2. Which of the following is a complete and accurate list of possible tutor(s) for Saturday?
(A) Blah170blah
(B) DumbHollywoodActor
(C) Blah170blah and Fritz A W
(D) Blah170blah, Fritz A W, and Nicole.hopkins
(E) Blah170blah, DumbHollywoodActor, and Fritz A W
3. If Amanda_kw tutors on Wednesday, how many options does Dillon have for scheduling DumbHollywoodActor?
(A) Two
(B) Three
(C) Four
(D) Five
(E) Six
4. Which of the following days can Nicole.hopkins tutor?
(A) Monday
(B) Wednesday
(C) Thursday
(D) Saturday
(E) Sunday
5. JY and Alan decide that Christopherblair having to tutor before Emli1000 is a silly stipulation. They fire Christopherblair, and Jonathan Wang must step in to fill the gap. However, Jonathan has some stipulations too. Assuming that the remaining rules still hold, which of the following demands could Jonathan make, such that the number of possible schedules created by poor Dillon remains unchanged?
(A) He tutors on Thursday only.
(B) He tutors before Nicole.hopkins and after Amanda_kw.
(C) He tutors before Fritz A W.
(D) He does not tutor on Saturday, and only tutors on Sunday if Emli1000 tutors on Tuesday.
(E) He tutors after Nicole.hopkins but before Blah170blah.
Let me know if I missed something and accidentally gave you an unsolvable game. Pretty sure I didn’t, but I often have too high an opinion of my abilities…
P.S. It would be so sweet if we could make A Game A Day ™, like, an actual thing. If anyone else wants to give this a try, I promise you it was surprisingly fun!
Highlight for answers >>>
1) A 2) E 3) D 4) C 5) B
Comments
I'm guessing A?
Also, that is correct.
↓
↓
↓
↓
1) a 2) e 3) d 4) c 5) b
Not gonna lie # 5 gave me pause (My least favorite sequencing question type) but your problem was pretty awesome, and very reminiscent of an actual lsat problem. Let me know how I did. Also, LSAC should hire you to write problems - then you can tell us the answers!
↓
↓
↓
↓
1) a 2) e 3) c 4) c 5) b
Dgelf321 - here are my four combos. What would be the fifth?
ceanfbd
ceadnfb
dcaenfb
ceanfdb
@sdiaz2030 Looks to be cdaenfb :-)
I got
1.A
2.E
3.D
4.C
5. B
2. E
3. D
4. C
5. C — I know everyone else got B for this but here is my reasoning.
C–E, A and D are the only ones who can occupy Mon–Weds (A/D/E/N can be on Thursday) since C–E and A all have to be before NF block and D is a floater. So "Assuming that the remaining rules still hold" (meaning that J–E?), it was never true that C had to go after A (but could have), and thus that would change the rule. Or am I missing something ?? Are we not just swapping J for C? or does J become a floater as well (detached from the C–E rule) and thus can be subject to whatever rules he wants? @"Jonathan Wang" is definitely the diva of this game ...
So choice C (given that NF still holds) would maintain that placement without introducing the additional constraint of A–J ... @#$@$%$^%
If I get a game like this on the actual test it will be a dead give-away of an experimental section ... OR WILL IT? #terror
Nice work, @pseudonymous
Q5 asks "Assuming that the remaining rules still hold, which of the following demands could Jonathan make, such that the number of possible schedules created by poor Dillon remains unchanged?"
i.e. we get rid of "C comes before E", but we must replace the rule with something that will create the exact same number of worlds. So while it's true that in case (c), J will come before the NF block, exactly as C did previously, now the replaced element (J) floats in slots 1-3 or 1-4, whereas before, C had to come before something. This changes the number of possible permutations. Does that make sense?
And LOL, you are right, Jonathan is totally the diva in this story.
Does anyone know of a game where a question of that type has appeared? I must ferret it out and destroy it.
SO, not only did you get to confirm that you done built a good game, you got to teach me (and terrify me) as well. So win-win-and win for me!
[also damn oprah lookin good in this pic ...]
But great job! My brain definitely got a workout.
1) a / 2) e / 3) d / 4) c / 5) b
http://7sage.com/discussion/#/categories/user-created-games