... sufficientandnecessary conditions and their relationship, however, I am confused when in a flaw ... question the author or speaker confuses a necessaryandsufficientconditionand what this means and ... confuses sufficientandnecessary conditions ...
... with flaw questions that have answers that "confuse necessaryandsufficient conditions." ... an apple is a sufficientcondition to being healthy since ... both types of confusions (confusingnecessary for sufficient / sufficient for necessary)?
... sufficientcondition for an argument's being inadequate"? Sometimes answer choices in Flaw ... between confusingsufficient for necessary as opposed to confusingnecessary for sufficient? I ... taking the necessaryconditionand moving it to the sufficient, which ...
... the difference between a necessaryandsufficient "switch" in a flaw question (i.e ... . 101 that a flaw that mistakes sufficient for necessary is one type of ... this is the 'mirror flaw' of mistaking necessary for sufficient, which we discussed ...
... the necessaryandsufficient conditions have been flipped (assuming this is the flaw). However ... necessarily pointing to confusion in necessaryandsufficientcondition? In my head, this ... />
Answer choices A and C is equally confusing. Are we supposed to ...
... br />
/NEOR ------> SVG and the contrapositive
/SVG -------> ... maybe a premise=sufficientconditionand that a conclusion=necessarycondition that maybe ... to decide what is the necessaryandsufficientcondition for choosing your answer. ...
... to whole, ad hominum attack, confusingnecessaryandsufficient... one you go thru a ... , the categories will start repeating and your ability to detect them ... a talk with Jonathan Wang and he said that one better ... that answer choice becomes the flaw.
Common Flaw Types:
• Uncertain use of ... negation/mistaken reversal (confusingnecessaryandsufficient conditions)
• Mistaken cause and effect- assuming ...
... being open minded is a necessaryandsufficientcondition for using the technique of ... Understanding. It is only a necessarycondition for the particular technique of ... of sufficient conditions. This leads to a lot of difficult andconfusing logic ...
... the stimulus thoroughly and know what the flaw is. Then, ... (wrong!)
3) Same flaw as stimulus (bingo!)
< ... identify the flaw (if there is one), and look for the ...
A) Not flawed
B ) Confusingnecessaryandsufficient
C) Too small of ...
@Daniel.Sieradzki : awesome explanation! Especially how you reconciled both the instructor's and @"Cant Get Right" 's diagrams by explaining how Open Minded functions as both a necessaryandsufficientcondition. Brilliant.
... understand the underlying logic and language of each stimulus/ ... these types of concepts, and each one goes pretty deep ... and has many fundamental subparts. ... of the relationship between a necessaryandsufficientcondition, all the time in ...
... />
>@terrynicholasj said:
>And then somehow, to my bafflment ... to decide what is the necessaryandsufficientcondition for choosing your answer. necessary andsufficientcondition for choosing your answer." (E ...
... biconditional relationship has a necessaryandsufficientcondition, so they trigger ... br />
K--------->/M and /M-------->K, with ... contrapositives M------->/K and /K---------->M sufficient to trigger it's necessarycondition.
... relationship has a necessaryandsufficientcondition, so they trigger ...
> K--------->/M and /M-------->K, with ... contrapositives M------->/K and /K---------->M sufficient to trigger it's necessarycondition.
...
...
> 7) Confusingnecessaryandsufficient conditions (PT22, S2, Q25; ...
> 9) Confusing probability for certainty
> ...
> 17) Confusing one possible solution for the ... and novelty fallacy
>
> 20) Confusing ...
... what you're talking about--confusingnecessaryandsufficient, while the second part, "failing ... that you might find helpful. And it's very good to ...
... if you Satisfy the Sufficient, or Negate the Necessary.
... since you negated the necessary, the sufficientcondition also can't happen ... necessarycondition can exist. However, in the second example, both the necessaryandsufficientcondition ...
... is in the sufficientcondition, N and M are INDEPENDENTLY sufficient for S. So ... or is in the necessarycondition, N and M and JOINTLY necessary for S. What ... that mean we need N and M BOTH to be selected ...