Also Antoine's C is the government shouldn't raise tax because (1) it is not fair and (2) to be fair you have to make everyone suffer from tax increase and not just gasoline users.
That's really helpful thanks! I can even see that if we take a few to be 2 or 3, then the support the premise gives to the conclusion is still weakened, because there are now fewer cases reduced by the switch than there was without it. Is that fair?