User Avatar
Tutor
ZoeLight
Official Score
176

Zoe studied Spanish and Public Policy at Vanderbilt University and will be attending Georgetown Law this fall. She spent one year as an English teaching assistant at a high school in Madrid, Spain, then spent two years working full-time in 7Sage's Tutoring Department. 

In her three years as an LSAT tutor, Zoe has worked with students with a wide range of experience levels. Zoe knows that each student has a different path to success, and she is committed to helping each student find the individualized study strategy that works for them. 

Outside of tutoring, Zoe enjoys reading, traveling, and hiking.

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT134.S1.Q5
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Wednesday, Mar 25

Student Question: What is the difference between implying that the conclusion is false and undermining the conclusion?

Tutor Response: For this concept, I would recommend checking out this lesson in the curriculum about truth vs. validity. In short, truth is a property of a claim (true vs. false), while validity is a property of arguments (valid vs. invalid). So when J.Y. talks about undermining the argument, he is talking about showing that the argument is invalid. This means that the truth of the premises does not guarantee the truth of the conclusion.

An argument is valid when the truth of the premises guarantees the truth of the conclusion. So when we say an argument's valid, we're not actually saying whether anything is true. Instead, we are making a claim about what would happen if the premises were true.

2
PrepTests ·
PT7.S1.Q24
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Tuesday, Mar 24

Student Question: How is PT7.S1.Q24 AC A correct? I keep diagramming but ending up with a sufficiency/necessary flaw.

Tutor Response: To see why (A) is a necessary assumption here, let's use the negation strategy. (A) diagrams as follows: Directly Bear--> Purposefully Sought. Remember, for an NA question, our goal is to find the assumption that the author must agree with.

The negation of the conditional claim in (A) becomes Directly Bear + /Purposefully Sought. (If you're unclear on the negation of this claim, check out this lesson on negating conditional claims.) So what happens to our argument if it's possible for findings to directly bear on the research, and also for these findings to have been found accidentally? Well, our whole argument would fall apart. The author is arguing that serendipity (or chance/accidental discovery) cannot play a role in scientific discovery. But the negation of (A) tells us that, actually, accidental findings can still make it through the grant-funded research process, which collapses the conclusion that serendipity is dead. Since the negation of (A) destroys the argument, we know (A) is the necessary assumption.

2
PrepTests ·
PT119.S4.Q14
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Monday, Mar 23

Student Question: I am having trouble understanding the context of the argument. What is the structure and reasoning of the argument? And how is the correct answer C as a result of the structure and reasoning of the argument?

Tutor Response: This stimulus starts out by explaining what other critics believe. So this isn't actually part of our author's argument; instead, this first sentence is context for the argument that shows us what the author is responding to. Specifically, these critics are arguing that the media has the power to impose opinions regarding important issues.

After this, we have our author's actual argument, which I'll outline here:

Premise: media showed a range of opinion that's narrower than consumers' range of opinion --> media has power to impose opinions

Premise: /[media showed a range of opinion that's narrower than consumers' range of opinion]

Conclusion: /media has power to impose opinions

This is pretty wordy, because our conditions are pretty wordy. So let's simplify this down so we can clearly see the argument structure:

Premise: A-->B

Premise: /A

Conclusion: /B

This is a pretty clear confusion of sufficiency and necessity. We know A-->B, and the author is assuming /A-->/B. But that's not a valid inference. This is why (C) is correct. (C) is pretty wordy, but it's referring to a sufficiency/necessity confusion. (C) says that the argument assumes from A-->B that /A-->/B, which is exactly the flaw that the argument made.

1
PrepTests ·
PT134.S1.Q23
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Monday, Mar 23

Student Question: Referring to question (D): If makes no sense --> promises should not be interpreted. So this is the exact bridge we needed but for me it was hard to diagram this out. I wasnt sure how I know which idea to make sufficient and necessary in the way this is written. How do I know in a answer choice like that in the way it is worded which is sufficient and which is necessary?

Tutor Response: I definitely see why it could be tricky to see the conditional relationship here, because we don't have a clear use of our conditional indicators. In these scenarios, I like to see if I can reword the claim to include a conditional indicator, but without changing anything about the meaning of the claim.

So here, I see (D) is telling me what I shouldn't do if I have a promise, so I'm going to reword it to say "No promises should be interpreted in such a way that they make no sense."

Now, I have a Group 4 conditional indicator ("no"), so it's a lot clearer where the sufficient and necessary conditions are. I know that "No" tells me to choose one of the terms, negate it, and put it in the necessary condition. So I'm diagramming (D) as promise interpretation --> /make no sense (or, as you said, make no sense--> /promise interpretation, which is the contrapositive).

1
PrepTests ·
PT123.S2.Q1
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 20

Student Question: Why couldn’t the conclusion be “which clearly harms the dismissed employees as well as the sense of security of the retained employees.”Wouldn’t the premise “Often, attempts to increase productivity decrease the number of employees” give support to this conclusion?

Tutor Response: For a claim to be a main conclusion, it needs to exclusively receive support from other claims. If a claim gives support to another claim in the argument, then it is not the main conclusion.

The claim "clearly harms the dismissed employees as well as the sense of security of the retained employees" shows us that some attempts to increase productivity have negative impacts. Because of this, it provides support for the statement that "not all efforts to increase productivity are beneficial to the business as a whole" (which is the main conclusion of the argument). Because the claim that you mentioned goes on to support another claim, it cannot be the main conclusion.

1
PrepTests ·
PT119.S3.Q24
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Wednesday, Mar 18

Student Question: Does the negation of (/belief -> disappear) get negated into (/belief + /disappear) because it’s an embedded conditional? I understand what the actual negation means now, but I think I’m still a little confused on how to recognize when a term is meant to keep its original negation and when it’s not. Thank you for your help.

Tutor Response: Check out this lesson on negating conditional claims! The negation of /belief--> disappear is /belief + /disappear because we are saying "it is not the case that disappear is necessary for /belief or that /belief is sufficient for disappear. In other words, if we negate the conditional of /belief-->disappear, we're saying that it's possible for /belief and /disappear to coexist.

In general, the negation of A-->B is A and /B.

1
PrepTests ·
PT143.S4.Q20
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Wednesday, Mar 18

Student Question: in terms of the last part of the video about noticing prescriptive versus descriptive claims, what was the significance there? is it that answer choice E was wrong because it was prescriptive and the stimulus was descriptive? can you make a general statement or rule that on any stimulus with only descriptive language any answer choice using prescriptive language is incorrect or can be eliminated?

Tutor Response: You're right that descriptive claims cannot support prescriptive inferences. Claims about what is the case cannot support claims about what should be the case. You can read more about this in flaw #10 on this list, "confusing is for ought."

In this question specifically, the argument doesn't talk about what "should" happen or whether we "should" preserve the forest, which is why (E) is not a necessary assumption.

1
PrepTests ·
PT153.S4.P3.Q21
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Wednesday, Mar 18

Student Question: Could you elaborate on what the author means by “In a sense, candor is an essential prerequisite of all other restraints on abuse of judicial power, for the limitations imposed by constitutions, statutes, and precedents count for little if judges feel free to believe one thing and say another”? I’m just having a hard time dissecting and understanding the concept of this sentence.

Tutor Response: The context of this sentence is the explanation of the importance of judges' honesty when they give reasons for their decisions. From context, we know we're about to see a reason that it's important for judges to be honest.

The sentence in question says that honesty is an essential prerequisite of all other restraints on abuse of judicial power. In other words, honesty is necessary for all of the other restraints on judicial power. If judges aren't honest, then the rest of the restraints on judges won't work. In the next part of the sentence, the author is telling us why they think honesty is essential: because the limitations on judicial power (these limitations being from constitutions, statutes, and precedents) won't matter if judges feel free to lie. So in short, this sentence is saying that if judges aren't honest, then we can't limit their power.

1
PrepTests ·
PT108.S2.Q24
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Tuesday, Mar 17

Student Question: Does the term “should” count as a Group 2 indicator (necessary condition)?

Tutor Response: "Should" is not a Group 2 indicator. You can review the group 2 indicators here. "Should" is prescriptive language/a recommendation, so it's not as strong as the necessary conditional indicators like "must."

In this stimulus, we represent the conclusion as sustain economic growth--> should radically modify techniques because the "if" before "choose to sustain economic growth" indicates the sufficient condition.

1
PrepTests ·
PT128.S3.Q7
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Tuesday, Mar 17

Student Question: Hello! For answer choice B, I wanted to know why I couldn’t have said that even though they already have other brand loyalties, that doesn’t mean they can’t become loyal to something else. For example, I was kind of thinking like I’ve been a long time costumer of Patagonia, but i recently saw advertising for the recently popular brand Arcteryx, and even though I like Patagonia I like the design of a new jacket Arcteryx was advertising, so I bought it and then started buying more from them. I didn’t originally think B was the answer because I thought well I can be loyal to more then one brand. I would have picked B if it had said “the older people are the less likely they are to try out a new brand if they already have brand loyalties to other brands of similar products”. Or am I thinking of it wrong? Also for AC (C), would it have been a better answer if it say the income of the younger adult was expect to rise and it’s going to be more then that of the older group? Thank you.

Tutor Response: The key here is that, for weaken questions, we don't need to completely destroy the argument. Instead, our goal is to make the conclusion less likely to be true, given the truth of the premises. So let's see how this works in this argument:

Premise: Average discretionary income of 65+ population will soon be greater than 18-25 population

Conclusion: In the future, it will be better for advertisers to target 65+ consumers.

So in short, we need a reason that might make it less likely to be true that it's better for advertisers to target the older group. You're totally right that brand loyalties can shift. However, it's also true that this argument is talking about broader trends across groups. (B) tells us that older consumers are more likely to have established brand loyalties. So, which group would be likely to have more people swayed by an advertisement: a group of younger people who generally have fewer brand loyalties, or a group of older people who generally have more brand loyalties? You're totally right that brand loyalties don't mean that people can't change their minds. But brand loyalties do mean that it's harder to change minds. It's okay if some people change their minds, as long as the general trend in (B) holds true.

With your example, with your previous brand loyalty to Patagonia, it would be more difficult to switch you to Arcteryx than it would be for someone with no brand loyalties at all. When we replicate this across entire groups, as the stimulus describes, we see that targeting a group that already has brand loyalties might not be as beneficial, even if that group has more money to spend.

Regarding (C), the stimulus already tells us that the discretionary income in the 65+ group will soon be greater. So it doesn't really matter if the discretionary income for the younger group increases, since it will still be lower relative to that of the older group. For your point with (C), we can't really say that the income of the younger group will be more than that of the older group, since the stimulus explicitly says that the income of the older group will be higher, and we can't directly contradict the information of the premises.

1
PrepTests ·
PT150.S2.Q5
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Tuesday, Mar 17

Student Question: What confuses me here is the “if and only if” in the correct answer - I’m a bit confused how that justifies the analysis. If and only if seems more like it it would disprove a situation in which the condition doesn’t apply. Not sure this question makes sense but I’m a bit stumped on this! I got it right on the PT and then incorrect on BR.

Tutor Response: "If and only if" is tricky. It actually indicates a biconditional relationship. In a biconditional relationship, each term is both sufficient and necessary for the other. We represent this as A<-->B. And, because of this relationship, we can infer /A<-->/B.

Let's take a look at how this applies in the context of the question. This is a PSAr question, so we need to find an answer choice that adds support for the lawyer's argument. Here's what we have so far from the lawyer's argument:

Premise: Doctors deliberately stop life functions

Conclusion: /functions resume--> guilty of manslaughter

There's clearly a pretty big gap here. The stimulus doesn't give any information about what makes someone guilty of manslaughter, so we know we need to add in a principle that tells us when someone is guilty of manslaughter.

(D) tells us: deliberately stopping life functions is manslaughter <--> the cessation is permanent.

Remember, the "if and only if" tells us that the conditional relationship goes both ways. And because this is a biconditional, we can also say that /deliberately stopping life functions is manslaughter <--> /the cessation is permanent.

(Is this what you meant when you said that it would disprove a situation in which the condition doesn't apply? If so, you're totally right. The biconditional tells us that, when the cessation of life functions isn't permanent, we can't say that someone who deliberately stopped life functions is guilty of manslaughter.)

Because (D) gives us this link between being guilty of manslaughter and deliberately stopping life functions, (D) supports the lawyer's argument and is our correct answer.

4
PrepTests ·
PT150.S3.Q22
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Tuesday, Mar 17

Student Question: On this question and in general, if it says “the argument is most vulnerable” should we be attacking or looking for gaps in the conclusion as opposed to the entire thing? I understand why E is correct but I am trying to get why A is wrong.

Tutor Response: This question stem asks us to describe the vulnerabilities in the argument, so we know this is a flaw question. For a thorough understanding of the goal of flaw questions, I'd recommend checking out the lesson here. In short, our goal is to identify an error in the support structure. So we're not looking for an issue with the conclusion in a vacuum; instead, we're describing why the argument as a whole does not provide sufficient support for the conclusion.

Now, looking specifically at why (A) is wrong for this question: (A) says that the argument identifies a cause of a phenomenon, but doesn't rule out the possibility that the identified cause might actually be an effect of the phenomenon. In other words, (A) says that the argument doesn't acknowledge that cause and effect might actually be reversed.

However, (A) doesn't apply here, because the stimulus doesn't actually try to establish a causal relationship! (A) is saying that the stimulus says X causes Y, but that it doesn't recognize that Y might cause X. But the stimulus isn't trying to assert a causal relationship, so reversing cause and effect is not the flaw here.

1
PrepTests ·
PT111.S3.Q13
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 13

Student Question: Can I request further explanation with this question?

Tutor Response: This is a flaw question, so our goal is to identify the mistakes that the author makes in their reasoning. To do this, let's start by taking a closer look at how the argument works:

Premise: There were never more than ~1,000 businesses in our region

Sub-conclusion: if businesses were really leaving at a rate of 4/week, they would have all been gone long ago

Conclusion: the Planning Board is exaggerating when they claim that businesses are leaving at a rate of 4/week.

However, what if the rate described by the planning board has only been 4/week for the past four weeks? If that was the case, then only 16 businesses would have left, meaning that we could have plenty of businesses left. The author assumes that this rate of 4/week has been the case for a long time––long enough for 1,000 businesses to have left! However, from what we see, the planning board never attached a time limit to their estimate. The president is inappropriately assuming that what is currently the case (that businesses are leaving at a rate of 4/week) has been the case for a long time. This is why (D) accurately describes the flaw.

1
PrepTests ·
PT144.S2.Q11
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 13

Student Question: I am still confused on how A is a good explanation for this question (PT 144 Section 2 Q 11). I understand how the rest of the answers are incorrect. For A to be correct, it seems like there are way too many assumptions that have to be made. For example, that the shoppers do not wait a few seconds after they enter the store and then turn around and see the on sale hammers next to them? Is it correct to say that they are basically assuming the shoppers walk into the store and ignore everything for the first few seconds and then once they get past the entrance then they take detailed notice?

Tutor Response: The key here is that this question asks which option does most to explain the result. In other words, it's okay if the answer doesn't perfectly guarantee a result, as long as it makes the result more likely.

Additionally, the surprising result is that the Styron hammers slightly outsold the Maxlast hammers. So, this means that it doesn't need to be the case that every single shopper bypassed the Maxlast hammers; if (A) introduces a general tendency that might slightly prevent shoppers from noticing the Maxlast hammer sale, that is enough to cause surprising result we see.

(A) explains the surprising result because it describes a tendency for people to walk into a store and not take detailed notice of what's around them. So if enough shoppers walk into a store and keep on walking/don't pause right away, then (A) does enough to explain the fact that Styron hammers slightly outsell Maxlast. And it could totally be the case that some shoppers do what you described (wait for a few seconds and turn around to see the sale hammers), because the difference in sales is just slight.

5
PrepTests ·
PT144.S2.Q21
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 13

Student Question: If I were to try to make (C) correct, would this work: “There is not a singular restaurant in the vicinity that has food good enough for Lena, Jen, and Mark. So there probably isn't any restaurant at all that would be good enough, so even though they would like to go out to dinner together after the movie tonight, they will probably go straight home after the show, considering restaurants are their only option.” ? So No one is good enough -> None are good enough, like in the stimulus No one disease powerful enough -> None of the diseases powerful enough ? And in (B) we have No one of us can fix both -> We (none, whole) can't fix both?

Tutor Response: Your process for (B) makes sense! The flaw in the stimulus is the jump between the premise that one individual disease can't kill so many different species, to the conclusion that human diseases probably didn't cause the mass extinction. This ignores the possibility that there were several different human diseases. (B) does something similar: from the premise that neither person could fix both things, (B) concludes that the pair of people can't fix the apartment, ignoring the possibility that one person could fix the door and one person could fix the window. In other words, both the stimulus and (B) are making the inappropriate assumption that the active agent must be acting alone.

You're right that (C) is flawed, but it doesn't have the same flaw in the stimulus. (C) is missing the inappropriate assumption that the active agent must be acting alone. I'm not sure that your proposed correction to (C) would work, though. (C) is wrong because the flaw it commits is that it doesn't consider outside possibilities, and it inappropriately limits the options for the movie-goers. Your proposed correction to (C) is still missing the inappropriate assumption that, because some cause can't have a certain impact on its own, that the certain cause at a cumulative level can't be responsible for the observed effect.

The structure for (C) that you created is: "no single restaurant meets all their standards --> therefore no restaurant at all is good enough." But that's actually a different flaw that conflates "no one place satisfies everyone" with "no place is good enough period." The meaning of "good enough" shifts, which is a different issue, and not the issue in the stimulus.

1
PrepTests ·
PT120.S4.Q15
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 13

Student Question: I didn’t know that I could apply conditional reasoning here. I definitely would have gotten this correct if I was able to. Should I apply CR to every question even if it isn’t needed? If not, how do I know when to apply conditional reasoning to some questions v leaving it out? Thanks!

Tutor Response: I would not recommend applying conditional reasoning to every question. Conditional logic is a specific type of reasoning, and many questions you see on the LSAT will rely on other types of reasoning (like causal reasoning, reasoning by analogy, etc.).

Deciding when to approach a question by understanding conditional relationships/using conditional diagramming is an important skill. One thing I would recommend is to look out for conditional indicators like if, only, unless, and never. You can see more about these conditional indicators here.

You can also use the question type as a clue. While this is a generalization (and not a universal rule), question types that focus on logical validity, like MBT and SA questions, tend to use conditional reasoning more often.

This question in particular is tough since it doesn't use conditional indicators. However, if you find that you can re-phrase a claim and use conditional indicators, that's a good clue that conditional reasoning will be helpful. For example, we can rephrase the first sentence to say "If someone has a doctorate in the liberal arts, then they are interested in improving their intellects." (Keep in mind that here, I didn't change anything about the meaning of the sentence, which is the key.) This is why we can represent this as liberal arts-->improving.

1
PrepTests ·
PT117.S4.Q20
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 13

Student Question: I just wanted to clarify for D in this question, when evaluating an answer choice that claims that the stimulus made an assumption, I wrote out the following steps. Please let me know if this is right. Obviously it will become intuitive but just so I have a general understanding of this:

  • Could negate the answer to see if its an assumption

    • You can ask yourself what would happen if the author didn’t assume this (could the premises still lead to the conclusion?)

      • Does the author leave the possibility of the opposite open?

      • If yes, then this answer choices is a flaw (and hence the right answer) because the premises aren’t for sure leading to the conclusion

Tutor Response: I think it's a great idea to come up with a standardized approach to prepare you for different scenarios you might come across. I do want to provide one note about the strategy you've outlined, when you say "Could negate the answer to see if it's an assumption." Negating an answer is a great way to identify necessary assumptions, which means the argument cannot work without it. On flaw questions about assumptions, the answer will typically identify necessary assumptions in the author's argument, so negation can still be useful. But remember that while negation will identify necessary assumptions, not every assumption in an argument is a necessary one.

When the answer choices for flaw questions are about assumptions the author makes, here is what I like to do:

1) Is this something the author actually assumed in the stimulus?

2) What would happen if this assumption didn't happen? (as in, negating the answer choice).

This way, we make sure we are choosing an answer choice that's descriptively accurate, and that the author needs for their argument (which makes it a flaw).

1
PrepTests ·
PT124.S2.Q8
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Thursday, Mar 12

Student Question: could you explain further on why B is right and C is wrong?

Tutor Response: This is a parallel flawed method of reasoning question, so our goal is to first identify the flaw in the stimulus, then identify the answer that demonstrates a similar flaw. To do this, let's start by taking a closer look at the stimulus and how it operates:

Premise: Studies show that the average airline has 1 accident every 5 years

Premise: If an airline hasn't had an accident in the past 5 years, it's more likely that it will have a crash

Conclusion: Vacationers should choose an airline that has had an accident in the past 5 years.

Basically, the writer is telling us that, because the average airline has one accident every five years, if the airline had an accident within the past 5 years, we're in the clear until after the 5 year mark. But this clearly isn't how averages work! Maybe several airlines had a bunch of accidents in a short period of time due to faulty equipment, then fixed the issue and haven't had an accident for many years. Or maybe one airline has a ton of accidents, and the rest of the airlines never have accidents. Either way, there are many ways to interpret the average of 1 accident/5 years, and this does not necessarily mean that we're in the clear if our airline crashed within the past 5 years.

So we're looking for an answer that uses a misinterpretation of averages to make a prediction about the future. Let's see why (B) works here:

Premise: The chance of an average adult male baboon becoming dominant in any given year is 1 in 10

Conclusion: If an adult male baboon has been in a troop for more than 10 years and never been dominant, then his chances of being dominant this year are more than 1 in 10.

Just like in the stimulus, we are getting information about an average (1 in 10 chance of being dominant each year), and the author is misinterpreting this information to make a prediction about what will happen. Average chances don't tell us that the chance is equal for each member in a set. It's just that, an average. If one baboon in a group of 10 has a 90% chance of becoming dominant and the rest have a 1% chance, then the average for group of the baboons is still about 1 in 10, but for most of the baboons, their chances are still well below 1 in 10. The information about the average rate of ascending to dominance doesn't let us make a prediction about the future for any individual baboons.

While (C) does involve a misinterpretation of averages, it does not use this misinterpretation to make an inappropriate prediction about the future. (C) gives us the average chance of something occurring on a given day, then applies this average to a specific individual on a given day. However, this does not use an average from the past to make a prediction about the future, which is what the stimulus and (B) do.

1
PrepTests ·
PT129.S4.P3.Q13
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Mar 6

Student Question: I am a bit confused on the explanation for D-doesn’t the question say that the author of passage a read passage B so it doesn’t really matter if passage A didn’t bring up the idea of a realistic novel, right? Also, for most RC questions, is it best to pick an answer that aligns best with the principles of both passages-which E does? Please let me know, thanks!

Tutor Response: You're totally right that the question asks what would happen if author A read passage B. However, it still does matter what passage A brings up/doesn't mention. This is because we are asked to identify information that author A would be likely to agree with. We can only know author A's opinion about things that are mentioned in passage A. Yes, author A would be exposed to the ideas about the realistic novel by reading passage B, but since this topic isn't mentioned in passage A, we just don't know enough to say whether author A would agree with this claim.

Regarding your second question, in general for RC comparative passages, the question stem will tell you which passage to focus on! I would not recommend that you always chose an answer that aligns with the principles of both passages, because lots of questions about comparative passages do only focus on one passage. For this question specifically, (E) works because we do need something mentioned in both passages, since we need something that author A would agree with after reading passage B. The reason for this isn't because it's generally best to pick an answer that aligns best with both passages, but because this question specifically asks us for something that requires information from both passages to answer.

1
PrepTests ·
PT109.S4.Q11
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Thursday, Mar 5

Student Question: How can I use the contrapositive, like in the explanation video, but not think about it as if I am negating everything? Can you better explain the results and how you got to the correct answer?

Tutor Response: I think the key here is recognizing that, while negation is part of the process of forming a contrapositive, the contrapositive itself is simply another way of expressing the exact same logical relationship. In other words, A--> B communicates the exact same thing as /B--> /A.

Let's apply this concept to this question specifically. Here's a breakdown of the argument:

Premise: Apes are the only creatures (other than humans) that can learn human language

Premise: Apes have never used human language skills to ask philosophical questions.

Conclusion: Only humans can engage in philosophical thought.

We see here that the author makes a conclusion about who can engage in philosophical thought, but our evidence is about using human language.

So, our author is assuming that, if you're not using human language, then you're not engaging in philosophical thought. If we represent this in a conditional diagram, it would look like this: /human language-->/philosophical thought.

Now, let's look at (C) in a conditional diagram: philosophical thought--> human language. We see that this is the contrapositive of the assumption we identified above. So, even though they're written differently, they're communicating the exact same idea, since they're in A-->B and /B-->/A format.

1
PrepTests ·
PT150.S3.Q6
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Feb 20

Student Question: Why can C be right but not E?

Tutor Response: This is a strengthen question, so we are looking for an answer that, if true, would make the truth of the conclusion more likely given the truth of the premises.

To understand why (C) works here, and why (E) doesn't, let's take a quick look at the argument itself to see what support we have already, and what gaps we might be looking to fill in to strengthen the argument:

Conclusion: The still waters around Shooter's Island are a nursery for juvenile waterbirds.

Support: The waters around Shooter's Island have more juvenile waterbirds than the waters around other islands, even though the total numbers of waterbirds are similar.

This is a causal argument; the author observed a phenomenon (that the total # of waterbirds is similar around the different islands, but that the # of juveniles is higher around Shooter's Island), and the author's conclusion was a hypothesis to explain this (that there are more juveniles around Shooter's Island because it's a nursery).

(C) makes this hypothesis more likely, because it connects still waters to nurseries. We know that the waters around Shooter's Island are exceptionally still compared to other waters. So if still waters are used as nurseries, this makes it more likely to be true that there are more juveniles around the island because it's used as a nursery.

(E), on the other hand, actually weakens the argument. (E) tells us that, when there's a nursery, waterbirds are more abundant. However, the stimulus tells us that waterbird abundance is similar around all of the islands (so in other words, waterbirds are not more abundant around Shooter's Island). So since it's not the case that waterbird abundance is higher in areas that serve as nurseries, then if (E) were true, then it's less likely that the water in question is a nursery.

2
PrepTests ·
PT125.S1.P2.Q8
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Friday, Feb 20

Student Question: I am going to note why I am confused on some of the answer choices explanations. A-this doesn’t have support from passage B since it only refers to one type of drilling muds as including clay; C-this doesn’t have support from passage A because the studies that are done are not environmental; D-I didn’t think this had support because just because passage B said that it is a tightly regulated industry, how can you infer that that is the government that is doing that regulation?. I was wondering if you could let me know if I am correct in thinking this: When drawing the line between what you can infer and what you can’t, a way to tell that you are going too far when making an inference for RC is to evaluate how far the inference is as compared to other answer choices? Like if the work you are doing to choose that answer is less than the others it is correct, even if it seems like it's unsupported-it is the best of the answers presented? Please let me know if that applies here or not as well to other RC questions. Thank you!

Tutor Response: First, I'll address your general question about RC inferences, then I can clear up your questions for each of the answer choices.

In RC, you're totally right that you can compare different answer choices to see how much "work" you need to do to support different claims. However, answers for implied RC questions will always have at least some level of support; they will never be unsupported. The support might not be super strong, but it will always be there.

If you're deciding between two different answer choices to see which is supported from the passage, think about which answer has direct support from the passage. You should be able to identify the specific parts of the passage that lend support to the answer you're considering. If you find yourself thinking, "I could see how X is supported IF I assume A, B, and C," then that's probably not your answer, because you need to do a lot of work for that answer. It's totally fine if your selected answer requires an assumption, as long as this is a more reasonable assumption than the other answers would require.

For these implied questions, the right answer might not be an air-tight valid inference with 100% support, but it will always have some support. (If you're confused about this distinction, check out this lesson about the spectrum of support!)

Meanwhile, RC stated questions typically require a higher level of support, since they're looking for something explicitly stated in the passage. This is analogous to the distinction between MSS and MBT questions in LR; all of the right answers will be supported, but MBT answers need to be 100% valid inferences, while that's not necessary for MSS.

Now, turning to this specific question:

This is a tough one, but the good thing is that the four wrong answers need support from one or both passages. That means that it's okay if you identified support for an AC in just one passage; that's enough to eliminate it.

Your note for (A) said: "this doesn’t have support from passage B since it only refers to one type of drilling muds as including clay"

As I mentioned above, we can already eliminate (A) because it's supported by passage A, which says "Drilling muds are made of bentonite and other clays and polymers" at the beginning of P2. But we also see support (albeit weak) for the claim in (A) in passage B. Remember, "many" just means "some" in the context of the LSAT. And the statement says "many, if not all." To support "many, if not all," we only need to show that it's true of many clays. J.Y. explains this in a bit more detail at 19:40 in the passage explanation video here. In passage B, we see that WBMs are made of a mixture that includes clay, which provides some support for the claim in (A) that clay is an important constituent of many drilling muds. But, as mentioned earlier, the support in passage A is enough to eliminate (A) as an answer.

Your note for (C) says: "this doesn’t have support from passage A because the studies that are done are not environmental"

The support for (C) in passage A is certainly weak, and (C) is better eliminated because of its support in passage B. However, that doesn't mean that (C) is completely unsupported from passage A. Passage A references a problem in studying the effects of drilling waste, which shows us that there have been studies of the effects, in general, of drilling mud discharges. Passage A also tell us that the drilling-mud discharges might have toxic ingredients, which tells us that we know something about the environmental effects of the discharges. Together, this provides tentative support for (C). You're right that passage A doesn't explicitly mention environmental studies, but it tells us that there have been studies, and it mentions environmental (toxic) effects.

Your note for (D) says: "I didn’t think this had support because just because passage B said that it is a tightly regulated industry, how can you infer that that is the government that is doing that regulation?"

This is where reasonable assumptions come in. You're right that passage B does not explicitly mention the government. However, passage B does say that the industry is tightly regulated. In the absence of another specified governing body, we can assume that regulations come from the government, because "regulations" refers to standards set by an authority or governing body, which would be the government.

1
PrepTests ·
PT105.S2.Q19
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Thursday, Feb 19

Student Question: Technically, don’t both premises support the conclusion in B as well?

Tutor Response: The key here is that in the stimulus, each premise independently supports the conclusion. With each premise on its own, we can support the conclusion. Here's what this would look like if we broke each premise out on its own:

Premise 1:

French dept --> max 1 intro class

Alban is in French dept

_________

/Alban teaching two intro French classes

(Because we know he can only teach a max of 1 introductory classes, so it's impossible for him to teach 2 intro French classes).

Premise 2:

language class taught --> advanced

Alban teaching language class

________

/Alban teaching two intro French classes

(Because all language classes are advanced, AKA /intro, so it can't be true that Alban is teaching two intro French classes).

This is why (B) doesn't parallel the stimulus. We're looking for an argument where each premise independently supports the conclusion.

If we break down (B), here's what we have:

Premise: Revised tax code doesn't apply to pre-1900 buildings (pre-1900-->/revised tax code)

Premise: Only first section applies to 1900-1920 buildings (1900-1920-->first section)

Premise: NB built in 1873

___________

/revised code applies to Norton Building

Here, the first premise independently justifies the conclusion. The tax code doesn't apply to pre-1900 buildings, so it doesn't apply to the Norton Building. However, the second premise doesn't independently justify the conclusion. The second premise says 1900-1920 building --> first section applies. We can say /1900-1920 building, since the Norton Building was built in 1873, but negating the sufficient condition doesn't allow you to do anything with a rule. The rule just doesn't apply in this case. This is why (B) isn't parallel.

3
PrepTests ·
PT139.S4.Q9
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Thursday, Feb 19

Student Question: Is wild/uncultivated not the negation of cultivated? So couldn’t you use the same symbol for those two?

Tutor Response: Yes! Uncultivated is the negation of cultivated, because there are only two options: either something is cultivated or it isn't. Because of this, you can use the same symbol for each concept.

When different terms are used in the stimulus, you want to be careful to make sure one term is actually the negation of the other. In this case, it works, but in an example like "hot and cold," we wouldn't want to represent it as H and /H, because "not hot" isn't the same thing as "cold"; there's middle ground there.

2
PrepTests ·
PT102.S3.Q15
User Avatar
ZoeLight
Thursday, Feb 19

Student Question: In order to do NA, you have to do MBT and then negation. How can u gather fertility about ac B at all from the stimulus?

Tutor Response:

You're right that, for a necessary assumption question, we need to identify an assumption that the author must agree with. And from the stimulus, it seems like we don't know enough about the author's opinion about (B) to say that it's a necessary assumption. But if we take a closer look at what we know from the stimulus, we can see why (B) is necessary here.

The argument's conclusion says that trimming rhino horns will ensure the survival of the species, because the rhinos are at risk of extinction due to the illegal trade of their horns, and trimming their horns will eliminate the motivation for poaching.

Right away, I see an issue here. Sure, trimming the horns will take away the current factor causing the extinction risk, which is poaching. But remember, our conclusion says that trimming the horns will ensure the survival of the species. What if the rhinos need their horns un-trimmed to survive? Maybe trimming the horns gets rid of one extinction risk (poaching) but introduces a new extinction risk by taking away something that they need to survive.

This is why (B) is a necessary assumption here. (B) tells us that some rhinos with trimmed horns will be able to attract mates. If the species is going to survive, the rhinos must be able to attract mates to reproduce. So, while the stimulus doesn't mention attracting mates specifically, this falls under the umbrella of "ensuring the survival of that species," because we know that reproduction is necessary for a species to survive.

We can also use the negation strategy here. If we negate (B), it says that none of the rhinos with trimmed horns will be able to attract mates. Well, the plan in the stimulus is to trim the horns from all rhinos. So now, none of our rhinos can attract mates. Sure, this generation of rhinos will be safe from poachers, but they will also be the last ever generation of rhinos if they're not reproducing. Then, our species won't survive. If (B) is negated, the argument falls apart.

1

Confirm action

Are you sure?