User Avatar
stephend
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

User Avatar
stephend
Monday, Jul 29, 2024

"Cogent" has a specific meaning in the study of formal logic. I would recommend becoming familiar with as many formal logic words and concepts as possible while preparing for the LSAT.

0
User Avatar
stephend
Wednesday, Jul 24, 2024

This definitely didnt feel like a 2/5

31
User Avatar
stephend
Wednesday, Jul 24, 2024

All cats are mammals.

That animal is a mammal, therefore it must be a cat.

Cat→Mammal is correct. (If it is a cat, then it is a mammal)

Mammal→Cat is incorrect. (If it is a mammal, then it is a cat.)

Do you see what is wrong with the reasoning when you mix up the sufficient and necessary conclusions?

Being a cat is sufficient for being a mammal, but it is not necessary.

There are plenty of other types of animals that can be classified as a mammal. Bears, giraffes, and whales are all mammals.

14
User Avatar
stephend
Wednesday, Jul 24, 2024

I also made this assumption, which is apparently wrong. I assumed that Penn appearing in the conclusion would imply that he was eligible based on record but failed some other requirement.

2
User Avatar
stephend
Tuesday, Jul 16, 2024

The piece you're looking for is the comparative claim in the stimulus. "More likely now than it was five years ago" is comparing conviction rates in two different times. So the stimulus says there are less car thefts overall, but more convictions. This is the discrepancy which needs to be explained. One would naturally assume that more car thefts would equate to more convictions, but this is the opposite of the phenomenon described in the stimulus.

3
User Avatar
stephend
Tuesday, Jul 9, 2024

I also interpret "vacuum tubes" as a superset. The rule applies to all vacuum tubes, including the small experimental vacuum tubes.

It would be irrational for the writers to assume that we know about the nature or size of vacuum tubes in general.

2
User Avatar
stephend
Tuesday, Jul 9, 2024

This one was pretty clear cut for me. The stimulus says in ALL other significant respects. Even if there were 100 other significant respects, missing even one would make them not preferable to semiconductors. So even breaking ONE of those rules (not matching max current capacity) disqualifies the vacuum tubes entirely.

12
User Avatar
stephend
Sunday, Jul 7, 2024

Was it a faulty assumption to assume that

decreased cost of living → more people living downtown → more traffic congestion → /profit increase

That seemed like a fair enough assumption to me.

I guess the entire last sentence is nothing but a trap.

0
User Avatar
stephend
Wednesday, Jul 3, 2024

The syllabus hasnt gotten to other question types which use comparatives and other lawgic concepts yet. This is simply identifying premises and conclusions.

6
User Avatar
stephend
Friday, Jun 14, 2024

When forming the contrapositive of a conditional relationship such as Z→REC, you must switch the sufficient and necessary conditions AND negate both of them in order to get an equivalent conditional relationship.

Thats what a contrapositive is- an equivalent conditional relationship, but expressed in a different (but logically equal) way.

This leaves you with /REC→/Z

3

Confirm action

Are you sure?