User Avatar
BennettBlake
Joined
Apr 2025
Subscription
Free

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
Not provided

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P4.Q22
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Sep 27, 2023

One of the most brutal passages I've ever dealt with in RC. RIP.

10
PrepTests ·
PT146.S3.Q20
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Aug 29, 2023

Wish a little more attention was paid to E in the explanation. This is a reoccurring trap I have noticed on some sufficient assumption questions. LSAC wants to bait you by giving you a conditional that if fulfilled would allow you to draw the conclusion. But in this case, it is only restating information we already have in the passage. We need to know that no lawyer was informed, not that if no lawyer was informed the contract was violated.

23
PrepTests ·
PT103.S1.Q12
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Aug 23, 2023

What I found to be a key phrase in answer choice C was that ants don't use pheromones to "guide themselves."

Sure, they might still use pheromones when temperatures are above 45 degrees but for all intents and purposes it is useless because it will evaporate.

On the other hand, I had a slightly different interpretation why E was wrong. Basically, there could be virtually an infinite number of other strategies these Sahara ants do employ when temp is above 45 C. It CBT that they have another strategy that makes them even more efficient when temperatures are hotter, just not pheromones.

1
PrepTests ·
PT146.S4.P4.Q23
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Aug 22, 2023

Totally agree, ended up picking A for this. I think it becomes a test of which answers are least bad. After all the question doesn't say it has to be true just that the passage "most helps" answer it.

For my AC, there is no support that they conducted lab experiments. On the other hand, everything that we learned about chlorine seems to suggest that it is the most damaging of constituent elements out there.

1
PrepTests ·
PT146.S1.Q12
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Sunday, Aug 20, 2023

If you picked E thinking that this strengthens the argument you are not alone. I still think it actually does (moderately), but in no way is the the AC that most strengthens the argument. That is the way the question stem is written, so you have to be surgical in executing that task.

For me personally, I eliminated C on first glance because of a misreading of the premise. I thought it just said "whether" and not "whether or not". I didn't want to fall for my millionth mistaken reversal so I got rid of it. Just shows you how 5 letters ("or not") can totally change the ability of a premise to provide support for the conclusion.

3
PrepTests ·
PT134.S3.Q14
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Jul 12, 2023

Honestly really happy I got this question wrong because I got to see a really fundamental flaw in the context of a really difficult question. As J.Y. identified in the video, the flaw here is that the author just gives a reason why Arnot's position might be false, which isn't sufficient to show that his conclusion is false.

The important thing is that the author has done nothing to support his position, which would have to be a reason why making fundamental changes to the government wouldn't solve these social ills. He just goes on the attack. In other words, our author's argument is all offense and no defense. He rejects Arnot's claim because he doesn't think a strong argument is made which is flawed.

2
PrepTests ·
PT134.S2.Q16
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Jun 27, 2023

J.Y. identified the pain point in this question really well but I wanted to reiterate it (mostly for my own sake bc I also incorrectly picked E.

This is one of those question were we have to choose between two really bad answer choices but one makes a lot smaller, overlook-able error. E will never be correct because it focuses on the wrong condition. That means that it cannot parallel the stimulus. On the other hand, A doesn't say that a belief in unicorns is false but says they don't exist. That implies that if you believe in them that your belief is also false.

The tricky thing is that this belief in things and their existence don't work both ways. For instance, I can say I don't believe in rainbows but that doesn't change the fact that they do exist. But if bigfoot doesn't exist then a belief in bigfoot would also be false.

2
PrepTests ·
PT10.S2.P1.Q3
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Friday, May 12, 2023

Q3 is brutal. To rehash what J.Y. was saying in the video about this question, basically the differential increased because black workers were not allowed in the craft union. On first glance, I took the passage to imply that black workers joining craft union increased the differential. This seems counterintuitive because it is so wrong, everything the passage tells us implies that union membership increases wages, especially for the minority workers in industrial unions.

What lines 47-54 are saying is that the wages increased for white workers since they joined the unions, but it had no effect on black workers since they were prevented from joining the union. This explains how the differential between their wages actually increased with the expansion of craft unions.

5
PrepTests ·
PT123.S2.Q19
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, May 9, 2023

For anyone who missed this question by quickly eliminating A (like me) I think there is a really great lesson here. For normal (not except) strengthen/weaken questions you must make sure that the right answer is focusing on the same subject. For this except question, the right answer shifts subjects.

The stimulus never even talks about "urban groups" but since your mind is keeping track of "rural" and "semirural" groups you just gloss over the word "urban" because you want to assume that they are referring to the same thing when you see the word "Land Party" and "group" in the same sentence. This actually is a fairly achievable 4-star question if you practice close reading by being thorough about the meaning of the stimulus.

23
PrepTests ·
PT131.S2.Q18
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Apr 19, 2023

I got at the correct answer in a slightly different way but it still appears consistent with the premise. I believe the passage implies that Malthus believes that food-producing capacity will not keep up with population growth, therefore all these terrible things. The author says actually it has kept up but we will still have all these terrible things happen. Imagine it in this abstract form.

Malthus:

A →C

A

_

C

Author:

/A -> B → C

/A

_

C

The way to avoid C is to see that although the author arrives at the same conclusion as Malthus, they do not believe Malthus' premise is correct. When considering an individual's "position" one has to consider the entire argument just not one part. Happy hunting.

0
PrepTests ·
PT114.S1.Q21
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Thursday, Apr 13, 2023

I've seen a lot of people, like me, take issue with the word "basic" because in what world is any Greek tragedy easy literature. Instead of individually responding to a thread, I think this deserves its own post.

This confusion led me to actually search up the definition of the word "basic", which seems silly but was actually really insightful. Basic only means "forming an essential foundation, fundamental." Colloquially, people use it to mean something that is easy or apparently obvious, which for anyone who has ever read a Greek tragedy knows is not the case. Any Greek tragedy, however, could be considered a useful starting place for understanding the essentials of all of them. They all rely on similar themes, have similar conflicts, and have a prose written in a certain way.

That said, I think the correct answer choice more appeals towards grasping the "investigatory techniques" which D clearly hits on. D also requires you to leave your own assumptions about how words like "basic" are used in order to accept this as correct. Tricky question, but I think it really comes down to confidently eliminating A and going with the answer choice that is most supported.

4
PrepTests ·
PT107.S4.Q13
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Apr 11, 2023

NEVER MISS ANOTHER DISAGREE QUESTION AGAIN!

Well I guess I can't promise that but this trick has saved me many times, especially on a trickier question like this where the area of disagreement is strongly implied rather than explicitly stated.

The point at issue has to be something each side has not only a stance on but also a stance in opposition to the other person.

In this question, D is a trap because the plant manager doesn't say anything about the fuel-efficiency of the closed furnaces. On the other hand, ask yourself why the supervisor is making the argument the way they are. What do they want you to believe? Well maybe the new process is actually more cost effective. That thought process will lead you to the right answer, even when the point at issue is not directly stated by each speaker.

17
PrepTests ·
PT132.S2.Q17
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Apr 5, 2023

IMHO I think this is probably the hardest question on this LR section, maybe even within the whole test.

The difficulty in this question I have seen many times over in 5-star LR questions where the stimulus will be a fairly common-sense argument. This allows LSAT writers to use one of their favorite traps of appealing to prejudices.

The reason that appealing to our prejudices is bad is not always because it directly leads us to choose wrong answers, but because it will lead us to overlook the answers that are correct because we expected something and more in line with our common-sense (like E the popular wrong answer.) At least personally, I hated choosing answer E because I just felt that it was wrong, but I wasn't seeing anything that I thought was better.

Seeing J.Y. write it out, this is a fairly standard transitive argument (A →B→C) that parallels closely with Question 14 in Section 4. In that question, we were asked to weaken based on the missing piece in the transitive. Whereas in this question, we are asked to supply the missing piece: the A→B relationship that allows the author to draw A→C.

Not sure if that is the best way to explain it, but this question is obtainable if you break it down to a very fundamental level. I promise you will see questions on transitives like this in the future.

6
PrepTests ·
PT132.S4.Q14
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Apr 4, 2023

Despite getting this answer horribly wrong, I actually really like it as template for understanding where to attack arguments by analogy.

The stimulus goes likes this -

Telecom:

Privatize → Competition → Benefit to Customers

Natl Park:

Privatize → Benefit Visitors

Looking at it this way makes it really easy to see the assumption that was made. I don't think this is last time I'm gonna see this on argument argument by analogy type questions. By removing the competition piece from the natl parks it makes it less likely that this premise (the analogy) actually supports our conclusion.

3
PrepTests ·
PT120.S3.Q20
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Thursday, Mar 30, 2023

I can't wait for the day on the LSAT when a claim is "self-contradictory." I see this all the time as a popular wrong answer and I thought I finally found it.

An example of a self-contradictory claim could look like "We agree to disagree on everything." I'm sure you see the problem with this statement.

While the philosopher is trying to argue against the OPA the method is not showing how there is an inherent contradiction, even though his violation of the laws of nature piece seems to suggest that. It still doesn't.

Stating the definition of a key term is definitely the most elegant solution to this problem.

25
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q19
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Thursday, Mar 30, 2023

This question points out a common theme I've seen in some weakening questions where you are comparing two things and then making a judgement about which one should be adopted.

The stimulus will point out one, or maybe even a couple different characteristics that make thing X better than thing Y. The correct AC often comes down to thing X being less effective in some way than the thing it is trying to replace.

Keep this assumption in mind when you read about two things that are getting compared.

18
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q24
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Thursday, Mar 30, 2023

Tough questions but I think there is a lot to learn from this. We are asked to find a case in which it does not make sense to follow the principle. It would've been so much easier if they worded it that way.

C gets us there because it means it is irrelevant how the instructions are written because they aren't going to be used by most anyways. The instructions could be written in Klingon and it wouldn't matter because most find it easier without even using the instructions.

Really crafty way to point out the assumption that a seemingly common-sense principle makes which is that you actually need the instructions in the first place. I think it is a great drill for anybody to ask what assumptions underly common-sense, and whether or not those principles can always be followed.

1
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q13
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Mar 28, 2023

These questions about societies and morals might be the death of me. Got lost in the sauce and picked D b/c it seemed reasonable and that I only had to assume that self-interest was a duty. Not a great strat for a MSS kinda question.

I eliminated C after I read "all societies." I think JY had an excellent point in the video that even though our intuition tells us to avoid statements of totality on this test, in this instance it is alright because the stimulus is making claims about "all societies."

8
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q3
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Tuesday, Mar 28, 2023

How rude of LSAT makers too throw such a dense stimulus on the third question. This one threw me off my groove so in an effort to avoid this in the future I decided to dissect this question in BR.

I approached it almost like an RC passage where I 1) Summarized Arguments 2) Identified Argument Structure (premise + conclusion) and 3) Wrote out our "characters" and wrote their beliefs

For me, that process clarified it a lot. If you see a question that looks like it is written in a foreign language, don't panic and start picking it apart before jumping to the AC, as tempting as that is. Especially for a PSAr question, if you don't understand the stimulus, you are dead in the water.

3
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q26
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Monday, Mar 27, 2023

I thought this was a really interesting answer for how it is strengthening. What AC C does for us is expand the group that was given in the premise in support of the conclusion.

At first, the premise only gave us the people who improved most in composition was the same group that improved the most in writing automatically. It is an alternate explanation that these the kids in those two groups are just geniuses who learn everything quick, unrelated to whether or not they learned to write automatically the most.

AC C says that even if you improved a little in writing automatically you also improved in composition skills. In no way is this a perfect argument and my prephrase was an AC that said automatic writing skills leads to greater composition skills, not the other way around. Nevertheless, by expanding the group this phenomenon is applicable to, it does strengthen the argument.

2
PrepTests ·
PT120.S1.Q2
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Monday, Mar 27, 2023

On my BR I ended up changing my answer from B to D. I did this, similar to many in the comments, because of "animal refuges" and I also thought D engaged with the support in premise/conclusion because it is a way that efforts weren't wasted. For anyone used to the traps that LSAC throws in the harder weakening questions, I think it is fairly easy to think D might be correct based on the grammar in the stimulus.

AC D is wrong because it is too outside the scope and doesn't really address the core assumption in this argument which is about the alternative world in which "international effort"wasn't provided. How do we know that economic benefit is something we should care about? We don't. Additionally, recognizing the benefit doesn't mean the it is less likely the efforts weren't wasted. The core of the argument is using the rate of animal extinction as a premise, so answers about economic benefits is not really engaging with the support structure here.

Especially in the second question, look for answer choices that are more straightforward, even if the correct AC isn't perfectly worded. It is safe for these easier question to assume that "animal refuges" would be a part of this effort.

4
PrepTests ·
PT114.S1.Q23
User Avatar
BennettBlake
Wednesday, Dec 21, 2022

I choose AC E and for anyone still having doubts on why this is totally wrong here is my explanation. It is irrelevant whether or not these independent scientists know more/less about the study of food irradiation than the scientists who conducted the study. After all, people who are not experts in fields can find flaws that the experts make. I am sure it happens all the time. So even if it were true, it is not a reason the argument is even flawed.

That said, the Activist's argument is still wrong because they treat the fact that there wasn't proof to support an answer, as a reason you can definitively say the opposite of the finding is true.

Hope that helps for anyone who picked E, like me.

1

Confirm action

Are you sure?