- Joined
- Jul 2025
- Subscription
- Free
Admissions profile
Discussions
I think the problem for D is not just that it's too general and too broad. The conclusion literally says that there's this one instant of technical fix that didn't discourage risk-taking behavior so I think to get rid of D just because it's too general is not understanding this question correctly. This is a principle question, is D really the reason why the author wrote the stimulus? Is that really what we would say is the argument or the principle that the author used? It is just something that can be true, but not the answer to the question. I think RC have a lot of questions like this, where you have to step back and don't get hang up on every literal words and sentences that can be true or is true according to the passage.
A is attractive because it rules out an alternative cause. Okay so the aromatic plant is not for the adult starlings, is it for the nestling or is it to attract females? We still don't know and that's why D is better.
The argument is saying there's A and B, and A is not the cause and B is the cause, and by saying C is not the cause does not help the argument.
E is wrong because the author never claim that the amount of artwork already in the world affects the amount of aesthetic fulfillment derivable from any artwork. Maybe it does, maybe it doesn't but what the author is saying is that everything is already out there for everyone to enjoy, nothing can add more to your enjoyment. All the happiness is out there, all the money is out there, the maximum amount of something is already out there, so nothing else can make you feel more of something, and D is saying excuse me, I'm still suffering, what if all the happiness and all the wealth out there have nothing to do with me (true story), or at least not all of them are available to me, so any additional "artwork" can totally make me feel more aesthetically fulfilled.
A - This is very tempting because I was thinking the reason why moose herd continued to grow despite the fact that wolves prospered (Presumably from from eating goose - which I think if there's a different answer choice that say wolves are eating some other animals, it would help explain why moose are fine, too.) is that wolves don't eat enough moose to offset the moose that would have been eaten by other predators. However, A says "moving into the area" meaning those predators don't belong in the area to begin with, so moose number should go down with or without other predators. Telling us other predators are out of the picture still doesn't tell us why moose herd continued to grow. This would be a better answer if it says wolves also killed other predators that prey on moose that were already in the park.
C on the other hand tells us exactly what we need. Wolves are not killing enough goose to offset the moose that they saved by killing those diseased moose.
I had hard time getting rid of E because I thought the researcher is claiming that NF was the first government other than China to issue any form of paper currency and therefore if not every government left records how can we know if NF is the first? But the researcher is actually claiming that MC is not the first, not that NF is the first. Maybe there's government earlier than NF that issued paper currency but it doesn't matter because we're only trying to prove that NF did issued paper currency in 1685 and that those scholars are wrong about MC.
Also "every" government is too strong, argument works just fine if E is not true.
So Kant's view is regarding beautiful and purpose and we just have to keep in mind that there's no support that author of passage A disagree with Kant, at most she/he is silent on the matter.
B - Passage A's view "ceremony that reaffirms common values. Ceremony requires witnesses: enthusiastic spectators conversant with the rules of the performance and its underlying meaning."
If anything, "underlying meanings and common values" sounds like a purpose, whatever it is, it would not be INCONSISTENT with Kant's view.
C - "Too formal/Any historical period", this is an easy elimination because there's just nothing in both passage that talks about them.
D - Passage A talks about sport and only mentioned art to draw a contrast on how art is different than sport. This is an attractive answer because it's familiar subject matters and it seem as if we can somehow connect author of passage A to Kant, but there's just no support for it. "Equally well" is also a red flag.
E - Author of passage A never mention why there's constant experimentation for arts. She/he mentioned it to draw contrast with sport.
A - "the ONLY surviving measure of excellence, for many, is novelty and shock value..often resides in a work's sheer ugliness or banality" this is our support. I'm not sure if novelty and shock can be defined as purpose but Kant's view was about beautiful and purposiveness, so even though "ugliness or banality" might have a purpose to create novelty and shock value, it's just not Kant's view. And if anything, author of passage A seem to imply that contemporary arts can't find the beauty and purpose in arts anymore and that's why they had to resort to novelty and shock values, they are lost.
I thought serious means professional or like high school /college sport team, which sounds a lot more than just childhood participation. But I think that's just a very narrow use of the word. Serious participation most likely means the participation is substantial enough that people who took part in sports during childhood acquired a capacity to make discriminating judgments.
Also all other answers are worst than E. A and B are about arts so they're wrong. C and D are about being excellence at a sport, but passage A is about judging a sport, not excellence in a sport.
C - Everything can only be explained by A
D - A can explain everything
And D is our answer because theory of everything is about how everything can be explained by its fundamental components, not that everything can only be explained by its fundamental components.
Picked A because all other answer choices are bad but had hard time finding direct support for "often overlooked". But I think the support is coming from the first paragraph when the author mentioned " But POPULAR reports..theory of everything...are misleading ", it's saying that there's good amount of people who thinks modern physics are close to arriving at a theory of everything, meaning the theory didn't overlook anything and it includes everything. But author jumps in and said otherwise and went on and talked about complexity theory. And since "often overlooked" really just mean sometime some aspects are being overlooked, I think that's our support.
E is wrong not only because the author suggests that rights can exist without government recognition but also even if you missed that inference and thought E is factually correct, it is not the principle underling the author's argument. Don't forget to double check what the question is asking for by the time you get to answer choice E!
A and B are both about interpretation of the reform, so if you pick A then you have to pick B too. Same for C and D, criterion and requirement are the same thing so if one of them is correct, both are correct. Watch out for those kind of pair answer choices, those are traps.
If you lost track of the main point on both passages just like me and was confused why A is correct, see below.
Passage A first paragraph, "prehistoric human teeth can provide clues about when a population made the transition from a hunter-gatherer diet to an agricultural one."
Passage B first paragraph, "Evidence indicates that, over time, the population became increasingly dependent on agriculture."
Got this question wrong because by the time I got to the questions, I thought the subject and the main focus of both passages are about dental decay so even thought I don't like "strictly agricultural" in answer choice C I still picked it because A talks about development of agriculture and to me that was not the focus of both passages. Lesson learned, wrong descriptive word means the whole answer choice is wrong and I missed the point. There was no way I can go back and read the whole passages again under timed condition, but luckily this is the only question I got wrong, so it makes me feel better for the real exam, one mistake is not going to ruin all of the questions for you.
In addition to JY's explanation, I think E is also wrong because the passage stated that "Polyaspartate has since shown unparalleled success at eliminating scale in offshore oil production equipment" I don't think that is the same as "unsurpassed ability to reduce scale" because maybe other agents are better than polyaspartate in removing scales in other places, offshore oil production equipment is very specific.
Basically, I don't know what I want, but I know what I don't want. I don't know what I like, but I know what I don't like.
We don't know the intention, but we can still know what is not the intention.
A - Specific factors that cause business to do poorly does not matter in this case because we just have to know if they failed or not and if so, why is it that the successes are overestimated. Why or how they failed doesn't help the conclusion.
B - We don't know if historians only study the first-person accounts (mostly likely not unless told otherwise) And even if so, what are the present-day cultural assumptions? We do not know, you would have to make unwarranted assumption that those present-day cultural assumptions somehow cause the scholars to overestimate the successes of past businesses to make this work and that's just trying to make B the correct answer by doing all the works for it instead of accept the fact that it's not.
C - Do scholars give more weight to the public legal documents or the internal documents? We don't know. I think it's fair to say scholars look at both public and private documents if they're doing their jobs and so the fact that some document are more objective would weaken the argument if anything because now there's no reason to account for the overestimation of the success of past business.
E - Good for the scholars, that's why they are the scholars. This tells us nothing about why they overestimate the success of the past business.
D - This helps to explain the overestimate of the success of the past business by pointing out that the scholars cannot just account for the documents available to them to make estimations because it's not complete, not only that, the failed business records are missing, you can't account for what you don't know, hence the overestimation of the success.
C is wrong because an argument can be flawed in many ways and we have to pick the one that the author is guilty of, not just any flaws. C points out a flaw that author might or might not fail to consider. It is entirely possible that the author did consider the possibility that "scientists who accept an argument largely for social reasons also generally consider relevant scientific evidence before accepting the argument" but it doesn't matter because the author is saying, as the argument goes, you know what everyone else is doing this thing, so it's okay, we can do it too, and B captures that.
The argument is that despite dioxin-->abnormal hormone and that fishes have abnormal hormones, dioxin is unlikely to be the cause. The support the author provided is that Dioxin decomposes very slowly so even if paper mills shut down occasionally dioxin should still be there effecting the fishes, but fishes recovered, so it's saying dioxin-->no abnormal hormone therefore dioxin is not the cause, author use cause but no effect to support that something is not the cause of another thing. C weakens the argument by saying dioxin could still be the cause of the abnormality because dioxin is gone when the paper mills shut down, the river currents carry the dioxin far downstream so it's actually no cause, no effect not cause, no effect.
I got confused with the word presupposes because I thought it meant Trust -->Mutual Respect which is exactly what the first sentence says. But then I know A is also correct because I know I made the correct inference. I started to double check my works and question if presupposes really mean what I thought it mean. I like A better because if B is Trust-->Mutual Respect, then I didn't make any inference to get to the correct answer which is highly unlikely on a must be true question. I picked A and moved on. Always be carful of answer choices that doesn't require any work. LSAT writers are not that nice.
D and E can be use to eliminate each other.
For D, it doesn't have to be true that orangutans dislike being caged more than chimpanzees do, what if chimpanzees just don't know how to use tools like how E suggested?
Likewise for E, it doesn't have to be true that not all nonhuman primates understand tool use, it could just be that chimpanzees are okay being caged like how D suggested.
A and B have zero support whatsoever and so we're down to C. I don't like answer choice C but I don't know how to prove it wrong either like how I did with D and E. The key word is that in the stimulus the word "pretend" is used hence the deception.
@Holly33333 And B strengths because we want to connect erosion to the rubbish and how because of the erosion, those rubbish is now useless. Erosion doesn't necessary destroy things and even if they do, they don't necessary render those things useless, a lot can still be told just by examining ancient rubbish (isn't that what archeologist is doing?) B tells us that most durable items are gone and so whatever's left in the pits are really really just rubbish that's not going to tell us much about the ancient people.
E is wrong because the conclusion is about the rubbish in the pits and how the rubbish isn't going to tell us much about the possessions. We want to strengths the reasoning of the argument, which is about erosion. Items that were never discarded is irrelevant because they were never in the pits to begin with.
I actually think A is right because the last sentence of the passage stated that "With three such signs, an abstract and FLEXIBLE written form had arrived." One of the signs is the symbol that denoted to whatever it was that ancient people wants it to be, sheep, oils, metal, etc. If it's flexible then it's reasonable to conclude it can be replaced.
I think the best approach for this question is not trying to talk your way into how is author of B not necessarily endorsing the argument. (I can't for the life of me) I did this through process of elimination. B and C are wrong for sure because passage A does not argues for one view over another or invoke any commonly held principles. D and E are wrong because passage B does have an argument. Now I don't like A either but it's the only one where I was like..okay..maybe..
I think sometimes the question stem can help you get rid of attractive incorrect answer choices. I was between B Rational and D Rehabilitation and then I read the question stem again and its says "most closely related to which one of the following "concepts" in passage B" so this is not so much about the definition of the words but how its' being used in the passage B. I feel like "rational" is good enough in that author of passage A does talk about how blameworthiness should be removed because of X, Y, and Z and hence there's rational in the argument on why the legal system should become forward looking. I get rid of it because passage B use the word "rational" to point out how rational arguments will only get you so far, as in rational is not going to get you to the conclusion that the author is going to make, which is the opposite of what author in passage A is doing, forward looking is the conclusion.
The passage says traditional approach placed the highest priority on the discharge of debts and that the under modern approach, creditors are likely to recover less. This is opposite of D.
However, if you're like me and thought discharge means dismiss, then D doesn't contradict anything but you can still get rid of it because its too strong. "Ultimately" is not the same as "likely to recover less" and "placed highest priority". It's slightly supported but E just have better support because it's a weaker claim.