User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Joined
Aug 2025
Subscription
Core

Admissions profile

LSAT
Not provided Goal score: 175
CAS GPA
Not provided
1L START YEAR
2027

Applications

Stanford
Intend to apply

Discussions

PrepTests ·
PT139.S1.Q22
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Monday, Nov 9

This was a very interesting flaw that I haven't encountered before! As I saw in a comment, imagine an argument that says, "Most of our best sales reps are men, so we should favor male applicants." But what if most of the people who apply are men in the first place?!

What if the composition of the best sales reps simply reflects the composition of the original applicant pool? If you had 100 applicants and 95 were men, wouldn't you expect most of your best sales reps to be men as well, just statistically speaking?

Premise: Most successful people have characteristic X.

Invalid Conclusion: Therefore, having characteristic X makes someone more likely to succeed.

Flaw: What if most people in the original group already had characteristic X?

1
PrepTests ·
PT101.S1.P3.Q19
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Edited Monday, Nov 9

Takeaway: Be wary of answer choices that make comparisons by degree ("more," "less," "greater," etc.) rather than binary distinctions ("has X" vs. "doesn't have X"). Claims about degree require stronger, more explicit evidence because you need to establish how much of something each approach has. Binary distinctions are often easier to prove because you only need to establish whether a feature is present or absent.

Once you see why D is correct, it's so straightforward that I can't believe I missed it. The main difference is simply that policy capturing examines judges' opinions, while the second approach examines case transcripts.

A: I initially chose A because policy capturing says "each opinion," while the second approach says "all sex discrimination cases." I compared "each" vs. "all" and assumed the second examined more cases. But we don't know that! The first could examine 200 opinions and the second only 20 cases. We have no info about the total number.

B: This is trickier because I think it exploits not knowing what "litigants" means. Litigants are simply parties to a lawsuit (plaintiffs or defendants). Both approaches address issues relevant to litigants. Policy capturing explicitly identifies factors contributing to a plaintiff's success or failure, which obviously concerns litigants!

D: So obvious in hindsight! One approach examines judges' opinions, while the other examines transcripts, which can contain info not mentioned in the opinions. That's literally the distinction.

I think I overanalyzed minor wording differences instead of focusing on the fundamental distinction between the two methods.

1
PrepTests ·
PT122.S3.P2.Q13
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Monday, Nov 9

D is trying to bait you with how the passage uses the phrase "large geographical area." But if you look at the definition of "centers of style," literally in that same sentence, the two main verbs are "produce" and "disperse." So the correct answer needs to capture both production and dispersal, which C does.

I think D sounded right initially, but first of all, it excludes the dispersal part. More importantly, D attributes production to the various tribes rather than to a centralized group of artists. The passage describes one group producing works for multiple tribes, whereas D describes multiple tribes producing the works.

Then D says the art "differs subtly along ethnic lines." The passage does describe small stylistic differences based on client tribe preferences, but the key point is that the same family (like the Konaté family) produces the sculptures for different tribes. The recipients are multitribal, not necessarily the producers.

1
PrepTests ·
PT122.S3.P2.Q8
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Monday, Nov 9

I was between B and E and chose E.

A - This is what the author would think.

C - Also what the author would think (second sentence of the last paragraph).

D - Not mentioned. No clear timeline, but P2 and P3 suggest this has been happening for a while ("long tradition of sculpture production").

B - I think there are subtler reasons why this is wrong. First, the eyes/mouth examples in P3 show how the Konaté sculptors adjust small stylistic details based on client tribe preferences, even though the same family produces the masks. So this answer is almost mixing/mish-mashing various ideas from the passage.

Second, B suggests similarities come from standard techniques, which could be shared across different tribes. But if techniques are "standard" across tribes, you can't use those details to distinguish one tribe's work from another's, which goes against the historians' approach.

B might work if it said a specific tribe's techniques explain similarities, since that would link stylistic details to a particular tribe.

E - Correct. Even though I wanted E to explicitly mention style, tribal origin is, of course, important because the historians are trying to trace specific styles to specific tribes.

1
PrepTests ·
PT134.S3.Q17
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Sunday, Nov 8

I wanted to strengthen the claim that Alzheimer's is caused by microglia.

A - The causal chain is: Protein BA accumulates → Microglia attack deposits → Microglia release poisons → Healthy brain cells die → Cognitive deterioration. (A) simply explains the first step in this causal chain. It doesn't undermine or strengthen the claim that microglia cause cognitive deterioration.

B - Yes, immune cells = microglia. We know that AA is good for fighting Alzheimer's, and now we know that it reduces microglia, strengthening the causal claim.

C - We already knew that microglia attack the protein deposits? I guess C is just strengthening that premise, but it doesn't link that premise to the conclusion any better. It's like if someone says, "She is good at math, so she will be a good math teacher," and then C just says, "She is super good at math."

Strengthening a premise is not necessarily the same as strengthening the CONNECTION between the premises and the conclusion.

D - Directly interferes? Now it sounds like protein BA, not microglia, could be the causal factor. This introduces an alternative causal explanation.

E - Other diseases? Not relevant.

1
PrepTests ·
PT134.S3.Q11
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Sunday, Nov 8

B is really only the case when someone argues that we should do X because of reason Y. Maybe there are reasons A, B, C, and Y for doing X, but then someone says, "No, reason Y is a bad reason, so we shouldn't do X." You've only attacked ONE SINGLE reason for doing X, without addressing the others.

Also, yeah, the stimulus just says that the proposal is dishonest. We don't actually know whether the author agrees with or rejects the proposal. They could simply be calling Sigerson a hypocrite while still agreeing with the overall proposal, but thinking that Sigerson shouldn't be the one suggesting it.

1
PrepTests ·
PT13.S2.Q22
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Saturday, Nov 7

I think the explanation for D is slightly off. I chose D because Mark and Tina evaluate environmental harm differently. Mark focuses more on the direct harms of foam cups, while Tina takes a broader view of the product's life cycle (production, transportation, disposal).

D gets at the bigger question: How should we evaluate environmental harm? Just the direct effects of the material (Mark), or the broader chain of consequences (Tina)?

For example, Tina brings up petroleum, electricity, and water use in production, as well as transportation, none of which Mark discusses. She also mentions water pollution and methane, which are more similar to Mark's concerns. Mark does consider some production/disposal harms, but Tina goes further.

If only direct harms matter, that narrows the debate and potentially weakens Tina's argument. If broader consequences matter too, Tina's additional points become relevant.

So D asks how far along the causal chain we should look before deciding which product is worse for the environment.

1
PrepTests ·
PT139.S1.Q5
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Edited Saturday, Nov 7

You need to recognize that the conclusion compares decaf coffee to regular coffee, so the correct answer must help you evaluate the difference between the two.

A compares people who exercise regularly with those who don't, specifically looking at which group is more likely to drink decaf coffee. But this doesn't directly help you compare decaf coffee to regular coffee! A would be more useful if it had asked, "Whether people who exercise regularly are more likely to drink decaffeinated coffee or regular coffee."

I was initially down to A and C.

C: If the answer is yes, then it could be that caffeine helps protect connective tissue, rather than that decaf coffee damages it. If the answer is no, then you might be more inclined to conclude that decaf coffee causes damage. However, you would still need more evidence to support that conclusion, such as ruling out additional alternative causes.

1
PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P4.Q25
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

A - Directly contradicted by "pay the lawyer's normal fee plus an agreed-upon additional percentage of that fee." Yeah, they ARE getting paid more than the normal value of their services in this specific instance. That's the whole definition of an uplift fee!

C - This was hard to eliminate because of the phrase "thus to ensure that just compensation to plaintiffs is not eroded." I think if C had said "receiving an unjustly high proportion of the damages awarded to the client," it might have been more accurate because, yes, they're trying to prevent lawyers from taking a disproportionate share of the damages and leaving the client with little to nothing. But the problem with C is that it makes the client's subjective opinion of what's fair the standard.

1
PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P4.Q22
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

I incorrectly eliminated A because I thought this was what the author believed, but NOT necessarily what the LRCWA believed.

But I realize that the question isn't asking, "What does the LRCWA believe?" It's asking about the passage as a whole, which can include the author's opinions, the LRCWA's views, or just general facts stated in the passage!

Also, the problem with B isn't even just the distinction between "deserve" and "disproportionate." The line "This restriction is intended to prevent lawyers from gaining disproportionately from awards of damages and thus to ensure that just compensation to plaintiffs is not eroded" is about INTENTION, not actual outcomes, so we don't even know whether the restriction would actually accomplish this!

B says that these agreements "would normally not result" in lawyers receiving larger fees than they deserve, which makes a much more definitive claim about actual outcomes!

1
PrepTests ·
PT139.S2.P3.Q13
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

I incorrectly chose D here because I thought P2 and P3 were really emphasizing the contributions of the workers/amateur actors themselves. But even in P2, there's so much about how Valdez directed things, like prompting workers to do certain things, guiding them, and explaining what an acto should accomplish.

I failed to recognize the concession-pivot structure of the last sentence of the passage:

"The early development of the Teatro Campesino was, in fact (indeed), a collective accomplishment; still, Valdez's artistic contribution was a crucial one."

Meaning, yeah, sure, the development of the Teatro Campesino was a collective accomplishment, BUT Valdez still played a crucial role in shaping it.

D completely sidesteps Valdez's artistic contribution and focuses exclusively on the importance of the amateur performers.

1
PrepTests ·
PT155.S4.Q20
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

@NicoleCosta This is too late, but yes, E describes flawed logic. I wrote a comment addressing this, but E is essentially implying that the argument assumes "Having reading skills means that EVERY requirement for democracy is met!"

That's not true because democracy could have other requirements that aren't necessary conditions for reading skills!

We have the chain:

D → FC → WRO → RS

But what if democracy has other requirements that don't fall within this conditional chain? For example, what if democracy also requires checks and balances or an established country? Those requirements would branch off separately from D rather than fit into the existing chain.

Also, even if we know that reading skills (RS) exist, does that imply that free choices (FC) and well-reasoned opinions (WRO) exist? No! RS is a necessary condition for FC and WRO, not a sufficient one, so RS doesn't trigger FC and WRO, which are established requirements for democracy.

1
PrepTests ·
PT155.S4.Q20
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Edited Friday, Nov 6

I think E is saying:

The fact that reading skills are a condition under which democracy occurs implies that if reading skills exist, ALL of democracy's prerequisites are also met.

We have the chain:

D → FC → WRO → RS

But there are two problems with this assumption:

  1. Democracy could have other requirements that don't fall within this conditional chain. For example, what if democracy also requires checks and balances or an established country? Those requirements would branch off separately from D rather than fit into the existing chain.

  2. Even the requirements already established in the chain aren't guaranteed by reading skills! Just because RS exists doesn't mean FC and WRO exist. RS is a necessary condition for FC and WRO, not a sufficient one, so RS doesn't trigger those conditions.

So E does describe a potential flaw, but it's not what happens in the argument. For E to match, I think the conclusion would need to say something like, "Having reading skills means that EVERY requirement for democracy is met!" (without necessarily establishing that democracy itself exists).

1
PrepTests ·
PT108.S3.Q14
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

@AnaMariaEdwards I think you were focusing on the wrong part. B doesn't match the stimulus's structure, unlike A, so you were focusing on a qualifier that ultimately doesn't matter. You're right that "generally" is closer to "usually," but in parallel reasoning, the underlying structure matters most.

When looking for the correct answer, we want Miller to conclude the opposite of Wu (which all the answers do), but his reasoning should be that the OPPOSITE of the quality Wu brings up is BAD.

For example, in the stimulus, Wu talks about dishonesty, so following this rule, we'd expect Miller to explain why honesty is bad, which is exactly what he does.

For B to be correct, we'd expect Miller to explain why nonaggressive people are bad, perhaps because they DO get pushed around. But B sticks to discussing the SAME quality Wu brings up (aggression). Miller needs to switch to discussing the OPPOSITE quality.

In fact, the reason B is wrong is the same reason C and D are wrong.

1
PrepTests ·
PT108.S3.Q14
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

Things to look for:

  • Miller should disagree with Wu's conclusion and conclude the opposite (though this isn't particularly helpful for this question because all the answers do that).

  • More importantly, Miller's reasoning should explain why the OPPOSITE of the quality Wu brings up is also bad.

So Wu says: Dishonest → should not be elected.

And Miller essentially responds: Well, honesty is also bad!

The key is to focus on Miller's premise. Does Miller bring up the OPPOSITE of the quality Wu mentions and argue that this opposite quality is also BAD? Only A matches this structure.

B–D: All three make the same mistake: Miller discusses the SAME quality Wu brings up and says something positive about it. For example, in B, Miller should have explained why nonaggressive people are bad, but instead, he continues talking about aggression. There's no switch to discussing the OPPOSITE quality in B–D.

E: This one is slightly different. We need Miller to argue that "inexperience is also bad." He DOES switch to discussing the opposite quality (inexperience), but he says something neutral or even defensive about it, rather than something negative. Also, unlike in the stimulus, Miller switches to discussing a different candidate (Lyons), and we don't even know whether Lyons is inexperienced!

While in B–D, Miller discusses the same quality Wu brings up and says something positive about it, in E, Miller discusses the opposite quality (inexperience) but says something relatively neutral rather than negative about it.

1
PrepTests ·
PT13.S2.Q26
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Friday, Nov 6

I knew this was a sufficiency/necessity flip, but I had a hard time mapping the abstract language in B onto the stimulus. Focusing on the phrase "only condition" helped because I knew from the conclusion that switching suppliers was being treated as the necessary condition:

  • A condition: Switching suppliers

  • The phenomenon: Not showing a profit

So B is saying that the argument fails to establish that switching suppliers, which is one condition under which the company won't show a profit, is the ONLY condition under which the company won't show a profit.

In other words, switching suppliers is sufficient for not showing a profit, but the argument never establishes that it's necessary. The company could fail to make a profit for other reasons!

1
PrepTests ·
PT14.S4.Q9
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Thursday, Nov 5

@PLEASELETMETGETA190 Hey, BIG thank you for pointing this out!! I realized two major problems with my earlier explanation that I think reflected a hurdle I still face with sufficiency/necessity questions, but your comment helped me correct a mistaken mindset I had!

You're right that the "some" inference doesn't apply here. I'm writing this for my own benefit and perhaps for others who make the same mistake:

For this rule:

Premise: A –most→ B

Premise: A –most→ C

Valid inference: B ←some→ C

(The same starting group is NECESSARY; it doesn't work if you have:

A –most→ B

C –most→ B

and then conclude:

A ←some→ C

Example showing why this is invalid: Most dolphins live in the ocean. Most sharks live in the ocean. Therefore, some dolphins are sharks)

I've revised my explanation above to reflect what I think is a more accurate way of approaching this question: identifying the missing assumption the stimulus relies on and then VIOLATING that assumption (keeping the sufficient condition true but the necessary condition false) to expose the flaw.

1
PrepTests ·
PT154.S1.Q13
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Thursday, Nov 5

Looking at this again, two months later, I still got it wrong, but I understand better why.

Essentially, we have:

Given: A → C

Conclusion: B → C

The link we need: B → A

Because then we can tack on A → C and establish B → C overall!

Premise:

~distinguish homophones → ~accurate translation

Yes, the hard part is plugging in this assumption that not being able to distinguish homophones leads to inaccurate translation. That logically makes sense, but it may be hard to see if you're looking for concrete signals of what to diagram.

Conclusion:

~recognize grammar/semantics → ~accurate translation

Essentially, based on what we have established, the only way the conclusion can follow is:

~recognize grammar/semantics → ~distinguish homophones (which is the contrapositive of A)

If it were the other way around (~distinguish homophones → ~recognize grammar/semantics), you'd have two separate things branching out from ~distinguish homophones, and the conclusion still couldn't be established.

1
PrepTests ·
PT132.S2.Q19
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Edited Thursday, Nov 5

Diagramming rules to remember:

  • But = and in logical diagramming

  • When you see "no" → negate the necessary condition. It's sort of like the "unless" indicator: you can pick either component, and whichever one you negate becomes the necessary condition (for "unless," you negate the sufficient condition)

From mapping my stimulus, I already had:

  • fish and ~birds → gerbils → ~independently owned

I got confused by the "but" in D and thought I should keep "tropical fish" the same but only negate the "not exotic birds" part. I learned an important lesson: When you see "but," treat it as "and."

So D can be diagrammed in either of two ways:

  • fish and ~birds → ~independently owned (this is directly what we see when we diagram our stimulus)

  • independently owned → ~fish or birds (the contrapositive of what we have in the stimulus!)

In E, the "that" becomes an "and" as well: independently owned and ~fish → birds

1
PrepTests ·
PT8.S4.Q3
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Thursday, Nov 5

The key reason D is right and A/C are wrong is that D says, "Pat has shown me research." Basically, the correct answer needs to establish that the person's conclusion is supported by reasonable evidence, but the opponent dismisses it simply because of the person's behavior or something personal about them.

C is wrong because Susan doesn't provide any evidence to support her claim that rock climbing is safe. Similarly, in A, David doesn't provide any evidence to support his claim that the film isn't very good.

1
PrepTests ·
PT9.S3.Q25
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Thursday, Nov 5

I chose the wrong answer, E, and overlooked C.

For E, I missed that it said "population-driven growth." The thing that makes travel less safe is NOT the traffic laws, but a third factor (population growth). We're looking for a policy that has an intended goal but whose actual effect is CONTRARY to that goal. Funny how I missed this even though the stimulus explicitly stated that the growth was population-driven.

For C, I didn't like it because it didn't have the same causal mechanism as the stimulus: policy → causes X → causes Y → undermines the goal. There wasn't a clear cause-and-effect chain. Instead, C identifies a requirement that conflicts with the intended goal. Since the question asks about the relationship between the declared intent and a relevant circumstance, C works even though the mechanism isn't identical.

C describes a policy (building strong armed forces) with a goal (forestalling armed conflict), but a requirement of maintaining that policy (engaging in actual combat) conflicts with that goal. I should have noticed the contrast between "forestall (prevent) armed conflict" and "be used in actual combat."

1
PrepTests ·
PT8.S2.Q26
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Wednesday, Nov 4

For those who chose B:

I've noticed that answer choices that say "question the relevance of X" or "point out that X is irrelevant" are quite difficult to support. It's sort of like answer choices involving circular reasoning. There's a very specific situation in which they're correct, but most of the time, they're not!

Irrelevance means that the author dismisses something as not even worth considering. If the author engages with it at all, offers a different interpretation or analysis, or disagrees with it, the argument usually isn't about irrelevance!

The same goes for circular reasoning. If any new evidence is offered, the argument isn't circular (since circular reasoning requires the premise and conclusion to essentially say the same thing).

These two concepts can frequently trip you up because they're so vague and seem to apply to so many situations, but there are actually very specific (and limited) circumstances in which they apply!

2
PrepTests ·
PT8.S2.Q21
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Wednesday, Nov 4

I weirdly had a hard time liking E because of the phrase "calls into question part of Joel’s definition of myth." I thought Giselle was mainly questioning Joel's application of the definition of myth to the modern world! But I overlooked that Giselle says the myth of the machine is indeed a myth, even though it may not be a narrative. That's the part of the definition being challenged! Joel's definition requires a myth to be a narrative.

I chose B even though I didn't like the phrase "analogous position." I knew Giselle was offering a counterexample (a specific example that shows a general claim or rule is false), but I liked B's phrase "points out a weakness."

However, there is no analogy here. An analogy would be something like, "That's like defining movies according to the limitations of silent films and then claiming that movies no longer exist because modern movies have sound." An analogy requires a comparison between similar situations, often signaled by words like "similarly" or "like."

Takeaway: I've noticed that I tend to shy away from answers that are descriptively accurate but don't match the pre-phrase I had in mind. Here, I expected an answer saying that Giselle was criticizing Joel's claim about the existence of myths in the modern world. But E is still descriptively accurate! This happens in RC questions, too, where I expect a certain type of answer, and the correct answer doesn't quite match my expectations but is still factually accurate.

1
PrepTests ·
PT130.S2.P1.Q4
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Wednesday, Nov 4

Archaeological remains: Physical objects left behind from ancient times.

Surviving texts: Written records from ancient times.

I had a super hard time with this question because I didn't anchor myself closely enough to the definition in the first sentence. I got confused because P1 talks about how there isn't much cloth to examine and how things like loom weights were initially seen as useless and discarded.

But actually, if you look at the structure of P1, it's explaining how traditional sources of evidence have been unhelpful for studying ancient textile production because (1) the archaeological remains that could have been useful either perished or were discarded, and (2) the surviving texts are hard to decipher. So everything discussed in P1 (including the cloth and loom weights) actually falls under the category of traditional sources of evidence!

Yeah, if you just look at the definition in the first sentence, it's clear that re-creations of looms are things we're making in the modern day, so they aren't traditional sources of evidence. I eliminated D because I thought it came up much later in the passage and was therefore irrelevant.

2
PrepTests ·
PT122.S4.Q23
User Avatar
IsabelTing11
Tuesday, Nov 3

E is wrong bc the conclusion ("those who for the most part refrain from comparing themselves to others") is broad enough to cover the issue E points out. The conclusion is about ANY comparison to other people, not just comparisons to those who are better or worse.

I've gotten this question wrong 3 times over the years.

The premises establish:

  • compare better → self-disparagement

  • compare worse → dismissive

The conclusion assumes that:

  • NOT compare better → NOT self-disparagement (aka self-accepting, though this isn't a perfect negation)

  • NOT compare worse → NOT dismissive (aka accepting of others)

That's the sufficient/necessary condition flaw! The argument assumes that if you don't make these comparisons, you can avoid self-disparagement and being dismissive of others. But what if other things can still cause you to be self-disparaging or dismissive? That's exactly what D points out.

(Also, if there were an answer choice stating that the counselor makes an unsupported leap from NOT self-disparaging → self-accepting and from NOT dismissive → accepting of others, that should also be correct.)

In other words, the conclusion assumes that the premises instead established the REVERSE conditionals:

  • self-disparagement → compare better

  • dismissive → compare worse

If those reverse conditionals were established, we could take their contrapositives and arrive at what I wrote above (and then the counselor's conclusion would be more valid):

  • NOT compare better → NOT self-disparagement

  • NOT compare worse → NOT dismissive

1

Confirm action

Are you sure?