Wow that’s embarrassing. My Lawgic chain was correct and I still confused necessary and sufficient when it came time to answer the question. But my chain and contra positive chain exactly matched the video’s 😭😭😭😭
When first reading the question through, answer choice A immediately stuck out as the right answer before I read the other choices and I was close to just choosing A then hitting submit, but of course I'm like "No way it is that easy let me read the other choices".... and of course that second guessing is what makes me pick another choice.
My problem comes from seeing the inspired performance as necessary for the good show, not the other way around. Why is that incorrect? Is it the "if" condition? I just dont understand how its sufficient for a good show rather than having both sophisticated listeners and inspired performance as necessities for a good show.
Oftentimes, I do one of these questions, and I get it wrong, but I then do the blind review and get it right 😭 I need to be quicker and less hesitant when I'm answering these
Even though i got it wrong, I still feel good about it because I know where I went wrong. I crossed out A because of the exact reason you said most people would. Common sense. Due to our worldly experience, we come to the conclusion that even if there are no sophisticated listeners in the audience, that doesn’t mean there’s no actual inspired musical performance.
However, like you explained, if we’re in a world where we only know what the stim says then that would be exactly the answer.
I'm proud of myself for getting this right. It makes sense to understand this question as a contrapositive. Basically, if people aren't smart enough to understand music, then this leads back to a no-good show.
165 comments
love this i got it right lets go lawgic
Wow that’s embarrassing. My Lawgic chain was correct and I still confused necessary and sufficient when it came time to answer the question. But my chain and contra positive chain exactly matched the video’s 😭😭😭😭
Use the rules, did the diagram, took me 7 minutes and 52 seconds but I aced it
When first reading the question through, answer choice A immediately stuck out as the right answer before I read the other choices and I was close to just choosing A then hitting submit, but of course I'm like "No way it is that easy let me read the other choices".... and of course that second guessing is what makes me pick another choice.
Damn got me
had the right diagraming and still got fried
My problem comes from seeing the inspired performance as necessary for the good show, not the other way around. Why is that incorrect? Is it the "if" condition? I just dont understand how its sufficient for a good show rather than having both sophisticated listeners and inspired performance as necessities for a good show.
Oftentimes, I do one of these questions, and I get it wrong, but I then do the blind review and get it right 😭 I need to be quicker and less hesitant when I'm answering these
It took hours for it to click, but I am finally understanding lawgic.
i got it!!!!!!!!
This is the best I've felt since studying, picked A without a blink of an eye once I had the Lawgic down 😛
A just sounded to good to be true, I got to much in my head.
@KikeHernándezLuvr Literally same...the simplest answer may very well be CORRECT because the question is very clear in what it's asserting
Even though i got it wrong, I still feel good about it because I know where I went wrong. I crossed out A because of the exact reason you said most people would. Common sense. Due to our worldly experience, we come to the conclusion that even if there are no sophisticated listeners in the audience, that doesn’t mean there’s no actual inspired musical performance.
However, like you explained, if we’re in a world where we only know what the stim says then that would be exactly the answer.
Thanks for explaining.
IM GETTING ITTTT YESSS
makes no sense. So many of these are right and yet its a shot in the dark to get the "true right" one bffr
question Chain link: IMP->GS->SL->MR
ControP: /MR->/SL->/GS->/IMP
Answers Chain links:
A: /SL(sophist. listener) ->/IMP (inspired music perform.) CORRECT
B: /GS (good show) -> /MR (musical roots)
C: MR -> IMP
D: /MR -> GS
E: SL -> IMP
A is correct b/c it's the only answer that matches the chain link. the other answer doesn't follow any of the order in either of our chain links.
Diagramming this question was brutal for me. I got it wrong initially and in BR!
Ugh I listed all the conditional chains correct I just didn't know which one to pick after that
I'm proud of myself for getting this right. It makes sense to understand this question as a contrapositive. Basically, if people aren't smart enough to understand music, then this leads back to a no-good show.
No sophisticated listeners -> no good show.
Took me eight minutes, but I got it
@BenjaminWellington should we be worried about how long it took? im only on week 2
@jacky.yyyy_ nah youll get there if you keep practicing
took me a while but I got it
one of the first questions I got correct and under time at the same Time. I am excited about that!
But would it be valid to say that there was a good show because there were inspired musical performance?
Got the chain right and D caught my eye, hate the confusion lol
@TacoyaWilliams me too </3