- Joined
- Apr 2026
- Subscription
- Core
Admissions profile
Applications
Discussions
We are looking for what MUST BE FALSE. lets find the premises.
"...creating a database for all plant species has proved to be no easy task..."
"...botanists have been collecting and naming plants without realizing that many were in fact already named..."
"...and by using DNA analysis, new species have been separated from older classifications..."
what AC must be false?
A - this definitely could be true, this is highlighted as an issue in our premises.
B - we cannot confirm or deny this statement, therefore this definitely could be true.
C - we cannot confirm or deny this, therefore it could be true.
D - If botanists are currently finding errors in their classifications, that means it can be inferred that they have techniques for at least identifying this issue when it occurs. (D) must be false, considering our premises.
E - this could be true, given that the botanists have already been having trouble.
Lesson: answers in this case that we cannot confirm nor deny, could be true on that basis. (INNOCENT (true) UNTIL PROVEN GUILTY (false)).
(D) - suggests that currently, botanists have NO techniques for classifying whether plant specie names are being duplicated unnecessarily. The passage establishes that the botanists have identified their classification mistakes, (D) asserts something that cannot be true given the passage.
We are looking for the NA. lets find the premises and the conclusion.
Premises: "...In winter, the coldest water is at the top; in summer at the bottom..."
Premise: "...the changes in temp distribution or "turnover" occur in fall and later winter..."
Conclusion: "...if anglers want lake trout in partially iced over lakes, they should avoid summer fishing spots (deep water) and fish in shallow bays or close to the surface..."
BECAUSE
Main premise: "...lake trout will be found, as a rule, in the coldest water..."
What is the author assuming here?
"...the water is cold still, and trout will be found near the surface..."
The author, currently has no proof that trouts will be found near the surface of the water because we have no indication what time of year it is. we are given conditions to find trout, but the conclusion makes no allusion to the time of year. I think this is the missing assumption. we need answers that the reasoning cannot do without and be coherent.
A - irrelevant. the authors reasoning doesn't depend on this, it depends on the time of year. The passage is setting up an optimal condition for fishing trout.
B - irrelevant. eliminate.
C - This wouldnt change the authors conclusion, therefore it's not required.
D - this isn't a consideration by the author. the author only gives us conditions for trout fishing as a function of temperature in lakes.
E - "...in deep lakes that have ice residues, the "later-winter turn-over has not yet occurred..."
TRANSLATION
"...in deep lakes that have ice, the temperature change (cool back to warm) has not occurred..."
This establishes that trout will be near the surface. this is what the authors conclusion is, which is why (E) is required. otherwise, theres no confirmation that the fish would be anywhere else besides the surface:
"...and fish instead in a shallow bay or close to the surface off a rocky point..."
what conditions need to exist for this to be possible? for the water to be cold af.
(E) used substituted language, but still preserved the authors reasoning.
Lesson: Keep in mind that lsat writers will consistently substitute language to encumber comprehension. determine first what is needed by the reasoning in order to make sense, does it support the reasoning and conclusion?
We are looking for the a strengthen. lets find the premises and conclusion:
Premise: "...Teenagers tend to wake up around 8am, the time when they stop releasing melatonin, and are sleepy if made to wake up earlier..."
Premise: "...since sleepiness can impair driving ability...."
Conclusion: "...car accidents involving teenagers driving to school could be reduced if the school day began later than 8am..."
BECAUSE
Main Premise: "...when the schedule for Granvilles high school was changed so that school began at 8.30 rather than earlier, the overall number of car accidents involving teenage drivers Granville declined..."
Whats interesting here, is that the passage gives us evidence of something that has already happened, to support their conclusion. The conclusion has been confirmed already. so why are we being asked to find a strengthen?
A - this is a support, relating to teenagers in general (not Granville students), we will see if there is a better AC.
B - This suggests that teens who are well rested, perform better on a related metric. we will keep looking.
C - this has nothing to do with the authors premises. we are focused on kids that go to school. eliminate.
D - we are only concerned about the morning before school starts, not the evening.
E - This corroborates the authors claim, and the main premise:
"...the overall number of car accidents involving drivers in Granville declined..."
Also it includes:
"...accidents rose in the region surrounding Granville during the time they declined in Granville..."
This is a comparative distinction, which can serve as a powerful strengthener and weakener.
Although we don't know why accidents increased, the comparison provides way more support than (A) and (B).
(A) - draws a general quality out of the sample in general, not even the students at Granville. Is this more powerful than the effects on the student body at Granville Vs. Other schools? no.
(B) - This emphasizes on a quality of a general sample (teenagers) vs other teenagers without that quality. is this more effective than (E)? no.
Lesson: The right answer in this case was a comparative distinction between the student body at Granville vs surrounding areas, AND it reinforced the authors main premise. do not assume that new information can be disqualified on the grounds that you have to assume information, if it supports the premises, and draws a powerful distinction, then it is support.
Hi, I don't want to be cliche and tell you something you've probably already have heard, but I can tell you something I've learned that has helped me keep my head above water with this test. This test was designed to be difficult. It has been professionally optimized for the past 81 years, by law and logic professionals as a metric of grit. I'm sorry, anyone who is telling you they've been getting 170+ on timed PTs with only a few weeks of studying is lying to you. This test requires more than just raw ability, there are skills that have to be learned and hammered into a method, that you take with you on test day; this process takes months. There is a reason why less than one percent make the best scores past 176, thats less than 1,280 people out of 160,000 total test takers. Do not believe the hype, do not believe the shortcuts, or the progress other people have made. No one has gotten that high of score without breathing, eating and sleeping the LSAT.
Put horse blinders on and just practice practice practice practice. practice so much until you start dreaming about LR problems. I'm serious. Our brains are designed to learn, your brain will get the memo after time, that is a certainty. And if you don't see the progress you'd like, just remember, this test's purpose is to be difficult. its designed to select for potential lawyers, its designed to confuse you, bog you down, waste your time and discourage you. Skills will determine a lot of things but not all, and notice how I said skills; yes this is a skill based test, don't let anybody tell you any differently.
I can't tell you how many times I sat with my head on the table thinking, "...can I really do this? I can barely get a 150.." and this was AFTER spending close to a month studying after going part time at my job and being a recluse with this stupid test. It was almost discouraging in that no one tells you, you just have to keep going, you have to push past the failure, cause thats the only way we can get better. Im not smarter than you, I'm not more well read than you, I'm not a better student than you, but I can tell you thing forsure; anyone can be great at this test. Including you.
Take a day, do your favorite thing and when you study; study study study. Like your brain depends on it. Throw yourself at the material. Do not make the same mistake I did, and wonder which study method to do, who to listen to, which approach is the best for X, Y and Z problems; just jump in and get the familiar with the concepts, it does not matter if it takes 398457093478 problems to do it, it will sink in I PROMISE YOU.
I truly am sorry you're feeling this way, and if it's any consolation, the fact that you're feeling this way should tell you that this test and becoming a lawyer is important to you. It should be, it's a huge calling for any of us. We have to put our ego aside and just train. I wish you all the luck in your studies. If it helps you, when I sit down to study, I picture myself as Uma Thurman from Kill Bill, when she's beginning her tutelage under Pai Mei. If you have a second look it up. Anyways, good luck girl, we are going through it, but together!!!!!!
We are finding an answer that characterizes the the role of Youngs response to West's.
West conclusion: "...of our three quality control inspectors, Haynes is clearly the worst..."
West Premise: "...of the appliances that were returned to us last year because of QC defects, Haynes inspected half..."
Young Conclusion (I think): "...you're wrong that Haynes is the worst..."
BECAUSE
Young premise: "...haynes inspects significantly more than half the appliances we sell each year..."
What exactly does Young do here in response?
Without stating an actual conclusion, Youngs response is a defense. its a statement that serves implicitly as the conclusion, and explicitly as "support" (Haynes is not the worst inspector).
In responding this way, Young is disagreeing with West's "conclusion" (characterization of Haynes as the worst inspector).
A - West doesn't presuppose his conclusion. he states support for it. its not a circular argument (Haynes is the worst, because he's the worst). eliminate
B - Young doesn't pose a question. we are looking for an answer this is descriptively accurate of the method young responded to west.
C - Young does NOT reply with a dispute of the accuracy of the defected appliances that Haynes inspected. This is inaccurate.
D - Young doesn't argue that Haynes isn't that bad. in fact young argues that "..No, Haynes is not the worst inspector.."
E - "...denying "one" of the arguments "presupposition".."
Presupposition is an implicit assumption (belief) someone might bring unconsciously to an argument.
Young, in principle, denies Wests "assumption" that Haynes is the worst inspector, without doing too much verbal work.(E) characterizes implicitly what youngs method of response is. its first: direct refutation of opponents conclusion ("...But.."). and two: support of the opposite of the opponent's conclusion.
Lesson: The exclusion of a stated conclusion (..therefore...) does not mean absence of conclusion. Young had an assumption, and supported it. it was an entire argument. Functionally, it is an argument without having the appearance of one. The correct answer (E) descriptively characterized the method of response of Young. Consider what the author's (young) belief is; that belief is the authors conclusion in this case.
We are looking for a weaken. lets find the premises and conclusion.
Conclusion: "...neanderthals, living 60,000 years ago, preserved meat by smoking it..."
BECAUSE
Premise: "...burnt lichen and grass have been found in many neanderthal fireplaces..."
Premise: "...a fire of lichen and grass does not produce as much heat or light as a wood fire..."
Notice how we have a comparison. Lichen and grass vs. wood fires.
we need to strengthen.
A - "fireplaces" are we talking about any old fireplaces? or neanderthal fireplaces??? this may support, but the use of "fireplaces", serves a ineffective weaken. we'll keep looking.
B - "..no plants "that could be burned more effectively to" produce heat or light were available 60,000 years ago..."
we can simplify this convoluted language:
"...In the region containing the neanderthal fireplaces in which lichen and grass were burnt, no plants that could produce heat or light were available 60,000 years ago..."
The author uses as a premise: "..a fire of lichen and grass produces a lot of smoke but does not produce nearly as much heat or light as a wood fire..."
(B) incudes lichen and grass as the plants that can't be burned to produce heat or light.
This destroys the authors arguments, this kicks his ass, spits on them, tosses a roll of dollars bills on the floor and says "...Now clean yourself up..."
(B) suggests that NO plants that could be burned effectivelywere at these neanderthal sites. which doesn't just undermine the authors claim about the neanderthals using lichen and grass to smoke their meat, but further undermines that neanderthals smoked their meat at all.
C - this suggests that neanderthal men had to travel a bit to get their stupid grass to smoke it. ineffective.
D - "some" groups of neanderthals living "more recently" than 60,000 years ago developed methods of preserving meat other than smoking it.
This suggests "some" "different" "more recent" group of neanderthals, had methods for preserving meat other than smoking it. does this dramatically hurt the authors claim that 60,000 year old neanderthals smoked their meat? more importantly, does it weaken more than (B)?
E - this is irrelevant. eliminate. this suggests that smoking meat would have made the neanderthals more resilient during animal shortage. which is a strengthen claim.
Lesson: notice when answer choices use convoluted language to express simple ideas. this is a strategy by the writers to encumber comprehension. Keep this in mind with weaken and flaw questions.
We are looking for a strengthen. lets find the premises and the conclusion.
Premise: "....a H virus fragment is present in a chromosome of a finch and in precisely the same location in a corresponding chromosome of the junco...."
Premise: "...the fact that these two birds species diverged from each other about 25 million years ago..."
MEANS
Conclusion: "...that the H virus is atleast 25 million years old..."
What is the author depending on for their conclusion to be true?
Evidence: "...h virus is present in the exact same chromosome in both birds AND these birds diverged from each other 25 million years ago...."
A - "viruses"?? "can"?? What about the H virus? this isn't addressing OUR virus. we'll keep looking. this suggests viruses in general CAN affect the divergence of a species. does this support the idea that the h virus is 25 million years old? ineffective.
B - This supports the idea the H virus is a long lasting virus compared to other viruses, which may support the authors conclusion, but we will keep looking.
C - this confirms the authenticity of the premises used to support the authors conclusion:
"...a H virus fragment is present in a chromosome of the finch and in precisely the same location in a corresponding chromosome of the junco..."
(C) suggests that ALL OTHER viruses insert themselves randomly in chromosomes. and we know that the two birds have the H virus in the same exact location in their chromosomes.
this answer supports the idea of the H virus, when divergence is happening, will insert itself in the new species, in the exactly the same spot as the progenitor species. providing evidence for the authors conclusion. this is way stronger than (B).
The writers specifically obscured the concept of divergence in (C) and substituted:
"...when a virus inserts itself into an animals chromosome.."
you can put "divergence" back into (C), and it becomes the obvious answer.
"...when species divergence occurs, viruses insert at random chromosome locations.."
D - this would obscure the authors conclusion. This suggests that these others birds, which may have different origins alsohave the h virus. which would at best do nothing to support our authors conclusion.
E - this is a no factor. eliminate.
Lesson: identify main premises, and conclusion. when evaluating potential answers, keep in mind that LSAT writers WILL substitute concepts used in the passage with different language in the answers to bog down comprehension. it is your job to remain attentive to this trap.
What is the most strongly supported? lets look at the premises.
Premise: "...B began losing his hearing when he was 30..."
Premise: "...the loss continued gradually, but was NOT complete until late in his life..."
Premise: "...it gave his late music a wonderfully introspective quality compared to his earlier music...."
lets look for an answer that has the most evidentiary support given these premises.
A - we cannot conclude this. the passage speaks nothing on ability of Beethoven. Eliminate.
B - we do not know the outcome if he had not lost his hearing. passage never establishes this. eliminate.
C - ELIMINATE
D - The passage doesn't establish that Beethovens music a gradual rate of increase of introspectiveness until his death. the author makes a general statement:
"...it gave his later music a introspective quality, that his earlier music lacked..."
"later" does not establish "rest of his music". eliminate.
E - This can be safely assumed. the author describes his later music as having a different quality. Notice the inclusion of "later music" as the object being qualified in (E). this is SPECIFICITY. this is our answer.
Lesson: determine what can be absolutely supported by the passage. (E) was supported, in that the author establishes Beethovens music of assuming a "quality" that his earlier work did not have. His earlier work was entirely absent of this NEW quality that the later work had.
A - is incorrect in that we don't know whether any music of his was difficult to compose. its not contained within the passage.
B - is incorrect in that we know that the later music was "different", we had no grounds to assume that it was of better quality.
C - is incorrect in the music is itself described as introspective, not Beethoven himself.
D - this is incorrect because we do not know the end stage of Beethovens music. was it supremely introspective? idk. we don't know at all. we are only told that his later music had a "different" quality.
We are finding the flaw. lets find the premises and the conclusion and establish an inference.
Premise: "....revolutionary party has been accused of being overambitious, and having caused great suffering..."
Premise: "....since the party's goals are quickly achieved, and did not have enough power to cause the suffering..."
Conclusion: "...therefore, its clear that the party was not overambitious and caused no suffering..."
what is the authors belief here?
Goals being quickly achieved=not over ambitious
not having enough power to cause suffering=causes NO suffering
A - are these responses inconsistent? or are they just presumptive? this is not the main flaw of the author.
B - This is one flaw the author makes. the critics argue that the party caused "great" suffering, whereas the author concluded that the party causes NO suffering. what justifies the author to make that claim? this is our answer.
C - this is not considered by the author.
D - the authors conclusion did not hinge on proving this true, it hinged on the fact that these revolutionary parties quickly achieved their goals, and this meant that they were NOT overambitious.
E - why do this author need to prove this? he's arguing that the party isn't flawed at all.
Lesson: identify premises, and conclusion. determine what the author's main premise is, and determine what the author DOES NOT HAVE THE GROUNDS TO ESTABLISH. (B) is the most specific, and points to the key flaw the author made when concluding that the party caused NOsuffering.
A - is incorrect because this is not the MAIN flaw the author makes.
C - is incorrect because this is not in consideration
D - this is incorrect because this is a secondary flaw. the author makes a more extreme one.
E - the author is trying to argue the opposite of this.
The correct answer was an affirmation of the opinion of the author.
A - this is too weak, the author states in the first premise:
"...there is little doubt that the ice ages were caused by the unusually rich growth of vegetation worldwide..."
B - the authors main argument is NOT the potential causes of ice ages. they decisively argue on only one, which was rich growth of vegetation. eliminate.
C - incomplete. what about ice ages?
D - the author did not argue on the potential effects of rich vegetation that caused the ice ages. they simply argued that it was probably rich vegetation--depletion of CD--ice ages.
E - this mirrors the authors opinion.
Lesson: identify what the authors believes to be the case. the authors first statement (conclusion) was essentially the correct answer.
A - is incorrect because it suggests the author is undecided in their belief that rich vegetation was the cause if the ice ages.
B - is incorrect because it suggests the author made an argument on the secondary causes apart from rich vegetation, that caused the ice ages.
C - is incorrect because it is incomplete in its scope of the entire passage.
D - is incorrect in that it suggests the author made an argument on multiple potential causes of the ice ages.
We are find the SA. lets look for the conclusion and the premises. we will also find the inference the author used to make their conclusion.
Premise: "...Since, The Time Machine is classified as science fiction...."
Conclusion: "...This classification is inappropriate..."
Because....
Main premise: "...."great" dramatic novels have compelling characters., which The Time Machine has..."
Whats the inference?
Since The Time Machine has a quality that "great dramatic novels" have, it cannot be a science fiction novel.
This is basically the opinion of the author that lead to their conclusion.
A - does this guarantee that The Time Machine cannot be a science fiction novel? This just establishes that a novel with compelling character IS a great novel.
The correct SA, would need to account for great dramatic novels never being considered as science fiction. with (A), it suggests that great dramatic novels can still be classified as a science fiction novel. (A) functions more as a necessary assumption, it wouldn't exactly guarantee the authors conclusion, but it definitely supports the reasoning.
B - Okay. if this is true, which genres exactly? this function more as a reasoning support, rather than a guaranteeing principle that great dramatic novels are distinct from science fiction novels. This doesn't help our author to confirm 100% their conclusion (great dramatic novels cannot also be science fiction).
C - the author never argues for the qualifications of a science fiction novel (The Time Machine) to become great. the author claims that a science fiction novel and a great dramatic novel ARE DIFFERENT GENRES.
D - the author doesn't argue on the classification practices of literary genres in general. eliminate. it doesn't confirm our authors conclusion.
E - If this were true, then NO great dramatic novel (The Time Machine) can also be a science fiction novel. this is what the author believes to be true to make their case.
Lesson: determine conclusion and premises, and what the author believes to be true for them to make their conclusion. (E) suggests that any great dramatic novel cannot be also a science fiction novel. this confirms their conclusion.
A - is incorrect because the possibility still stands that The Time Machine, under this assumption can be great AND still be science fiction.
B - is incorrect because this is support for the authors reasoning, not a guaranteeing principle that would confirm the authors conclusion.
C - is incorrect because this is achieving a different aim than the authors.
D - Is incorrect because it is arguing something that the author did not consider in their argument. author argues on behalf of great dramatic novels, science fiction novels, and that they should NOT be considered the same thing.
B - this answer suggests that the tribes exchanged tools. does this support that neanderthals ARE nomads ? what if one tribe was not nomadic and the other tribe frequented the site occasionally in order to exchange tools??? the author can still claim their conclusion to be true. we needed an answer choice that suggested that the neanderthals are nomadic.
We are looking to weaken. lets find the authors premises and conclusion.
Main premise: "...found discarded teeth whose coloration indicated that gazelles had been hunted throughout the year..."
and this means
Conclusion: "...neanderthals lived at the campsite and are not nomads..."
Okay so we need an answer choice that attacks this reasoning. the author is depending on the the fact that these gazelles were hinted year round to be evidence of the tribe living at this campsite.
A - does this prove that neanderthals are nomads? this just means they hunted a wide variety of animals. the author can still effectively claim their conclusion. eliminate.
B - Doesn't support the idea that Neanderthals are nomads. (B) suggests that one of the two tribes in question could or could not be nomads. then the question still stands. The author can still effectively claim their conclusion.
C - This attacks the main premise the author used. (C) suggests that the hunted gazelle teeth theory is actually just neanderthals using these teeth as talismans, and discarded them whenever no longer useful. if a statement offers an alternate explanation for a phenomenon that differs from the main premise used to make a conclusion, then it weakens. this is our answer.
D -we need something to attack the claim for neanderthals, no cromagnons.
E - this suggests that gazelles were no migratory animals, which supports the author claim that the neanderthals are not nomads. eliminate.
Lesson: (C) suggested an alternate explanation for the hunted gazelle tooth theory. this is important because it challenges the main premise the author used to make their conclusion (it challenged what their argument rests on).
A - is incorrect in that it does not establish any support or detraction for the idea that neanderthals ARE nomads.
B - is incorrect because it leaves the possibility open that neanderthals are settlers.
D - is incorrect in that it refers to cromagnons rather than neanderthals. the authors conclusion rests on the consideration of the neanderthals.
E - is incorrect because it supports the idea that neanderthals are settlers.
We are looking for the discrepancy. let's find the two discrepancies. The correct answer will solve both issues that are stated in the passage, that create the discrepancy. it cannot just refer to one.
"...according to all crimes reported to local police departments, the incidence of crime per 100,000 people has risen substantially over the last 20 years...."
"...survey of randomly selected citizens give the impression that the number of crimes was less in recent years compared to 20 years ago..."
So our correct answer will need to address both of these situations.
A - would these explain the over reporting? no it would not. and would the experience of having been the victim of a crime be a requisite to be able to have an opinion on it? this would suggest that the people surveyed might have underreported or over reported their impression of crime. this throws more obscurity on the discrepancy.
B - this would suggest that the incidence of crime per 100,000 is actually higher. emphasizes the discrepancy.
C - this would explain the second discrepancy, but what about the possibility of over reporting? (C) gives us nothing about that. we will keep going.
D - equates accurately describing a crime to authenticity in the impression of crime. this throws more obscurity into solving the discrepancy. eliminate.
E - "...of "crimes committed in a country" (overall crimes?), a much greater proportion have been reported to local police departments in recent years, than were reported 20 years ago...."
Okay this definitely explains the first discrepancy. (E) also suggests that of the crimes committed, more are reported to police departments than were reported 20 years ago. That means less crimes in general.
crime committed 20 years ago: Gang sells drugs to local teens.
Does it get reported? Maybe.
Crime committed today: Gang sells drugs to local teens.
Does it get reported? Highly likely and to local police department.
Consequence: gang goes to jail. less crime.
This is an explanation for the impression of less crime with the general public.
Lesson: determine opposing situations. determine discrepancy. (E) solved both issues.
A - is incorrect in that it didn't resolve any of the issues. it offered more obscurity
B - is incorrect in that it doesn't resolve any of the discrepancies
C - is incorrect in that it only revolves one of the discrepancies. we needed the over reports claim to be solved.
D - doesn't help any of the discrepancies.
We are looking for the NA. FIRST lets find the conclusion and the premises and the inference the author uses in arriving at the conclusion.
Premise: "...the recipes' first step is to use cornmeal to clean the sand out of the mussels..."
Premise 2: "...the mussels available at seafood markets are farm raised and do not contain sand..."
Conclusion: "...therefore, I can skip the first step..."
How did the author get here? what inference did they make in arriving at their conclusion? Think of the inference as the unstated assumption by the author or their belief that assisted their reasoning and helped them arrive at their conclusion. what would that inference look like here?
"...since the mussels are from the seafood market, this means they don't have sand, and this means I don't have to use cornmeal, which means I can skip the recipes first step..."
Ookay now that we have an inference, lets look for the NA that the authors conclusion NEEDS to be as effective as possible. The correct NA, if negated, will make the authors reasoning seem absurd. you will think "...how the hell could the author have concluded that bullshit?"
A - the authors conclusion DEPENDS ON the mussels that they have, NOT HAVING TO BE CLEANED. This weakly addresses the authors conclusion. it definitely does not confirm the conclusion.
B - This would suggest ALL mussels do NOT have contaminants OTHER than sand. which does what for the authors argument? it doesn't affect it. it doesn't confirm it.
C - is taste being considered by gordon Ramsey here? the author is worried about the cleanliness of these lil mussels. not the taste. this doesn't address the authors conclusion. eliminate.
D - This would suggest that the chefs recipe is outdated. does this affect the chefs conclusion that he can skip the first step? The conclusion depends more on the fact that farm raised mussels do not need to be cleaned, rather than the accuracy of the recipe book. this is why the inference is handy. if it does not affect the inference at all, its not the correct NA.
E - This is exactly what the chef needs to argue to Gordon so he can be left alone to cook the damn mussels.
What is (E) negated?
"...the mussels the chef is using for the mussel recipe DID NOT come from the seafood market..."
whats our inference that we found initially?
"...since the mussels are from the seafood market, this means they don't have sand, and this means I don't have to use cornmeal, which means I can skip the recipes first step..."
what does negated (E) do to our inference here? it completely undermines it.
Lesson: the right answer (E) accounted for our premises, and confirmed our conclusion. The NA cannot assume beyond what the author considers in their argument. only an SA can do that.
A - is incorrect in that it does not affect the authors argument and it doesn't affect the inference. the inference is the beliefor unstated assumption the author has that assists them in arriving at their conclusion. If (A) were assumed, it doesn't help the authors case at all.
B - is incorrect in that it is irrelevant to what the author NEEDS to confirm their conclusion. it doesn't support our inference. Its also too strong. it assumes something beyond what the author considers.
C - is incorrect because the author never considers taste in their conclusion. it is irrelevant.
D - is incorrect because, the date when the recipe book was written, has nothing to do with the mussels the chef has, and those mussels being farm raised mussels from the seafood market. it is irrelevant.
We are looking for reasoning that is similar with the passage.
Lets frame the premises and the conclusion in our own words.
Premise: "...In the past ten years the station has never finished better than fifth place in the ratings..."
Premise: "....the stations manager has not responded to its bad ratings by any method..."
Conclusion: "...the station will not win the rating race this year..."
What is the inference the author makes in arriving at their conclusion?
"...Since the station has not done better than 5th place in 10 years, we will not win this year..."
Okay lets look for a similar reasoning in the answers.
A - "every" "all" this isn't similar to our inference. different modifiers used here. eliminate.
B - This seems similar, but it has a positive outcome as opposed to our situation. "...we will not win this year..." eliminate.
C - "all" this is a category assuming another category. not the performance based prediction situation we have in the passage. eliminate.
D - "recently" this is a time component we had in our situation. It also has a negative outcome at the end:
"...therefore they will be lower this coming Monday too..."
This is our answer.
E - "only" this is the same is (C) where we are considering categories of things, not outcomes of things. eliminate.
Lesson: the right answer (D) portrayed the exact same relationship with a component of time, and of our object having a negative outcome due to a prediction.
A - is incorrect because there was no time component, and it did not have a negative outcome.
B - is incorrect because it didn't have a negative outcome.
C - is incorrect because its a category situation which had no time component or negative outcome.
E - is incorrect because this is a category situation. no time component or negative outcome.
We are looking for what MUST BE FALSE. First lets find our premises and the conclusion.
Premise 1: "...on the basis of morphological differences, scientists suggest Neanderthals and CM are different species..."
Premise 2: "...the type of tools used by these two species living in different environments were exactly the same type, which indicates similarities..."
If two species use the same tools--same behavior
Premise 3: "...For ONLY if they faced the same daily challenges, would they have used the same type of tools.."
If two species use the same tools--faced the same challenges
Premise 4: "...morphological differences are due merely to their having lived in different environments..."
Conclusion: "...Therefore, they are the same species..."
What does the author DEPEND ON being true for their conclusion to be as effective as possible?
Premise 2 & 3. What is the inference drawn from this to arrive at the conclusion?
"...since these two species used the same tools (same daily challenges) AND they share behavioral similarities, they are the same species..."
Okay lets look for an answer that MUST BE FALSE.
A - This could be true. this is the stance of the opposing scientists. they believe that morphological differences DOsuffice on determining whether species are distinct. eliminate. we are looking for a statement that must be false if every single sentence in the passage is true.
B - This is a false statement, considering the premises.
"...the daily challenges with which an environment confronts its "inhabitants" (Neanderthals and Cro-magnons) are "unique" to that environment..."
The author established that the daily challenges faced by both species were the SAME, reinforced by the fact that they have the exact same type of tools. this is our answer.
This question in general is asking us: If you insert these statements (answer choices) in the passage, which statement must be false according to the premises? (which does not belong)?
C - The passage doesn't give us insight into disproving this statement. it could be true. we are given conditional relationships regarding (C). eliminate. If we can't disprove it, then it could be true.
D - This is inference the author is using against the opposing scientists. The author uses this belief to make us conclusion. It definitely could be true.
E - We are not given explicit information on the geographical locations of either of these two groups, ONLY that they lived in "different" environments. (E) could be true. we cannot disprove it.
Lesson: the right answer (B) was disproven by the facts in the passage. in fact, the question calls us to assume that every single sentence in the passage is a fact.
A - is incorrect because this was the position of the scientists. could be true.
C - is incorrect because this can't be disproven by the passage. this possibility may exist. the passage leaves (C) open to speculation. therefore it could be true.
D - is incorrect because this is the stance of the author. They believe this to be true. And since we're assuming that the passage is the truth, we have to assume that (D) can be true.
E - is incorrect because the passage leaves this open for us to speculate on. all we know is that these species lived in "different" locations. (E) could be true.
We are looking for a flaw in Boris's argument. FIRST lets find the conclusion, the premises, and boris's inference.
George: "....why is ballroom dancing popular now?..."
Boris premise: "...beginning in 1995, people learned many ballroom dances..."
Boris conclusion: "...therefore, that is why these ballroom dances you speak of are popular..."
George: "....ok....but why were they popular--nevermind..."
What is Boris' inference that he made to arrive at his conclusion?
"Since ballroom dances were popular in 1995, thats why they're popular now."
With this inference in mind, lets look for this flaw in the answers.
A - Boris never communicated this to George. in fact Boris didn't even put in this much effort. eliminate. This would be relevant if Boris had concluded:
"...these people that popularized merengue, started dancing the most modern ballroom dances, and thats why they're popular today.."
B - This seems relevant BUT , George never posed this question to Boris:
"...why was ballroom dancing unpopular at one time?"
(B) suggests that in this passage, George asked this question to Boris. which George never did. this is irrelevant from Boris' conclusion. eliminate.
C - Do we know forms of dancing that are more or less prevalent than merengue? this answer is meant to waste your time. eliminate.
D - "..account for the "beginning of the revival of interest" (popularity) in ballroom dancing..."
This is exactly the flaw that Boris makes. he basically says:
"it was popular, cause it was popular lol"
E - George never asked Boris to do this, and Boris' argument doesn't depend on answering this question. In this question, the right answer characterizes the best response to Georges question.
Lesson: Find the conclusion, the premises and the inference the author made in arriving at that conclusion. this can give you insight into what flaw the author made. Notice how the correct answer characterized the best response to George.
Imagine someone mediating this conversation between George and Boris. like a therapist or something.
George: "...okay Boris, just answer this one question for me, in the best way possible. Why is ballroom dancing popular today?..."
Therapist to Boris: "...okay Boris, before you start yapping, your objective in answering this question is to:
"account for the beginning of the revival of interest in ballroom dancing."
Boris: "...oKaayYYy."
A - is incorrect in that George didn't ask this of Boris, (A) also doesn't answer Georges question. this is irrelevant.
B - is incorrect in that it mischaracterizes Georges prompting of this discussion. George never asked why ballroom dancing was unpopular at any time. he simply wanted to know why it was popular today.
C - is incorrect in that it establishes a topic that was NOT present in the passage. Answering Georges question did not depend on relating merengue to anything. irrelevant.
E - is incorrect in that it is irrelevant, and mischaracterizes the discussion between Georgie and Boris. AND Boris does NOT base his conclusion on the popularity of a dance in comparison to other forms of ballroom dancing. NOR does George ask for a comparative reason why some dances are more popular than others.
We are looking for a weaken. FIRST lets find the authors conclusion, the premises, and the inference linking the premises to the conclusion.
Premise 1: "....a study shows people who regularly consume high doses of vitamin C supplements have a significantly lower than average risk of heart disease..."
Conclusion: "...Therefore, people who take vitamin C tend to be "healthier" than average..."
How did the author get from "lower than average risk for heart disease" to HEALTHIER??????????????
what's the inference the author drew from the premises to make their conclusion? Think of the inference as an unstated assumption the author might believe. it doesn't necessarily have to be correct, it just has to be consistent with the premises the author themselves used to make their conclusion. This will give us an insight into what the author believes.
Inference: "Vitamin C makes people healthier than average, because it was shown that Vitamin C lowers risk of heart disease."
How is this flawed? The author is conflating two things:
Vitamin C having ONE effect
AND
Vitamin C having a general effect (health)
Do you think one study on the effects of vitamin C supplements lowering the average risk of heart disease can PROVE that this vitamin C can make you healthier than average?
What if vitamin C has negative effects? the point is, the author cannot reliably conclude that vitamin C can ALSO makes you healthier in general.
Now that we have the flaw in the argument, lets looks for how we can weaken it. Keep in mind the inference we found:
Inference: "Vitamin C makes people healthier than average, because it was shown that Vitamin C lowers risk of heart disease."
A - "different" ? would the rate in which vitamin C is absorbed in the body affect our inference? would it weaken it? strengthen? do nothing? (A) just gives us insight into the rate in how vitamin C is absorbed. Do we know of a situation where absorption differs between supplements and food in the passage? NOOOOOOO. this is a WGC answer. WILD GOOSE CHASE. eliminate.
B - This would weaken the claim IF the author's conclusion was:
"...People who take vitamin C tend to have a lower than average risk of heart disease.."
The author concluded something entirely different:
"...People who take vitamin C tend to be healthier than average..."
This doesn't weaken the authors conclusion. eliminate. we need an answer that attacks our inference.
C - "vitamin E"? This suggests not ONLY vitamin C is responsible for effectively lowering the average risk of HD. But does the author make a conclusion about HD? NO, they conclude about heath in general, from data on vitamin C and heart disease. This irrelevant to the authors conclusion. WILD GOOSE CHASE.
D - "..vitamin C tends to reduce slightly ones resistance to certain "common" infectious disease..."
If (D) were true, this is a negative effect the author hasn't considered in vitamin C, which would affect overall health.
The author right now believes that ""Vitamin C makes people healthier than average, because it was shown that Vitamin C lowers risk of heart disease."
(D) would say: "...No, look vitamin C is actually bad for people, it reduces their resistance to common infectious diseases.."
E - This would strengthen. If vitamin C could prevent someone from developing cancer, it would be the holy grail of modern medicine.
Lesson: Identify conclusion, premises, and the inference the author used to make their conclusion. The right answer (D) attacked the authors "conclusion" (Vitamin C makes people healthier than average), by offering a possible negative effect of vitamin C. (D) also attacks our inference.
A - is incorrect because it does not weaken. Its irrelevant to what the author considers to be the metric for concluding that vitamin c makes people healthier than average. The metric is vitamin C lowers risk of heart disease. (A) attacks neither the conclusion or our inference.
B - is incorrect because it does not weaken. The author does not base their conclusion on vitamin C is the best vitamin to lower risk of heart disease. the conclusion rested on assuming that since VC lowered risk of HD, VC makes people healthier in general.
C - is incorrect because its not addressing the authors conclusion, and therefore doesn't have any effect. (C) would ONLY be correct if the author had argued "vitamin C is the ONLY vitamin that can help in lowering the risk of HD." the real conclusion relies on something entirely different.
E - is incorrect in that it would strengthen the authors conclusion. If vitamin C had this other massive benefit, this would support the authors claim that vitamin C makes people healthier.
We are looking of the main conclusion of Leslies argument. First lets find Leslies premises and conclusion in context of the overall passage.
Leslie 1: "...Ill show you that your quest for the treasure is irrational...would you lose your hand in exchange for the world?.."
Erich: "...NO.."
Leslie 2: "....since, your hand is more important than the world, and your body is more important than your hand..."
Leslie 3: "...and since, you are ruining your body in your questfor "treasure" (that is less valuable than the whole world).."
Conclusion: "...I rest my "case" (your quest for the treasure is irrational)..."
What is Leslies inference she is drawing from the premises to make her conclusion?
If you choose your hand instead of the world, and your body (which you are ruining in pursuit of this treasure) is more important than your hand, your quest for the treasure is irrational, since this treasure CANNOT be more valuable than the world.
Now that we have this inference lets look for the main conclusion.
A - This is a fact of the passage, but is it the main conclusion? this doesn't express what the author concludes of Erich. Eliminate.
B - "gains" do we know of any gains Erich might receive from risking his physical well being? or any gains of getting the treasure? we don't know the treasure. for all we know the treasure is walking 30 miles to get a bomb ass taco or something. this answer choice is meant to send you on a wild goose chase and waste your time.
C - "no value", do we know that this treasure has "no value"? From the passage, the only information we have that describes the treasure is:
"....yet you are ruining your health and harming your body in your quest for a treasure that is much less valuable than the whole world..."
This is all we know. (C) overreaches here. eliminate.
D - Erich can be convinced? (D) suggests that Erich gave an affirmative back to Leslie saying "..okay Leslie you're right, I won't sleep overnight at this Apple Store so I can be the first in line to spend $1300 on a iPhone Duo."
We don't have an answer back from Erich. In fact, the question is asking us only the main conclusion of Leslies argument. eliminate.
E - "...erich is engaging in irrational behavior by pursuing his quest for the treasure...."
This is Leslies first and last statement of the passage.
Leslie's case: "...ill show you that your quest is irrational..."
Leslie conclusion: "...therefore, I rest my "case" (your quest is irrational)..."
This is our answer.
Lesson: the right answer (E) identified Leslies premises, her conclusion, and confirmed the inference we found that led Leslie to her conclusion.
The wrong answers did not characterize and summarize Leslies position; either by assuming things that Leslie did not say, were incomplete summarizations or invited us to speculate on conditions that were not given to us in the passage.
A - is incorrect in that it states one fact from the passage, not the entire scope of Leslies argument.
B - is incorrect because it assumes that pursuing the treasure might bring Erich gains, when the passage never made mention of the gains from the "risks" (treasure) other than that it was less valuable than the world.
C - is incorrect because it assumes that the treasure is of "no" value, when the passage did not mention any qualitative value distinction of the treasure. all we know is that it is less valuable than the world.
D - is incorrect because it assumes Eric's position afterLeslies made her case. we only know Leslies last statement.
We're looking for the NA, which means our right answers to this question, if negated will undermine the authors inferencein arriving at their conclusion. The negated NA assumption is going to make you say "how the hell could the author concludes that???"
Lets look for the premises, the conclusion and what it DEPENDS ON to be true. we will get our inference from this relationship.
Premise 1: "...Charity rarely gives its donors the right to vote on its policies.."
Premise 2: "...inability to influence contributions makes donors feel less emotional connection..."
Conclusion: "...Charities could probably increase donations by giving donors "the right to vote" (ability to influence contributions which makes them emotionally connected).."
What's the inference here?
"if donors are more "emotionally connected" (given right to influence contributions), charities could increase donations."
Okay so now that we have this inference here, lets look through the answers.
A - This is basically saying "the most effective way for charities to give donors the right to vote, is to give them the right to vote on some things" Does this fit our inference? and would it affect the authors conclusion at all? we are looking for a principle, which fits in the context of the premises, and supports the reasoning behind the authors conclusion. in other words IT SUPPORTS THE AUTHORS INFERENCE AND THEIR CONCLUSION.
B - "..."most" charities that have increased donations have done so by making donors feel a greater emotional connection...". Okay, this addresses our inference, BUT would this confirm the authors conclusion if (B) were assumed? (B) suggests that at least some charities have achieved increased donations by NOT making donors feel more emotionally connected. Doesn't this cast some doubt on our inference AND the authors conclusion? This can't be the NA the authors NEEDS to confirm their conclusion in this circumstance. The correct NA needs to validate the strength of the premises and our inference. (B) undermines it.
C - This suggests that every charity that has given donors rights, has seen an increase in emotional connection. Although this is supportive this does NOT address the authors inference of "if donors are more emotionally connected, charities could increase donations." we need that link of "greater emotional connection=increased donation to charities". and (C) doesn't offer that. its incomplete. eliminate.
D - "..."most" potential donors.."?? are we concerned about "most" potential donors? we are concerned about most charities. Not donors. this modifier would weaken any claim on behalf of donors. we need something that accounts for donors, as well as their emotional connection, and how that relates to increased donations in charities.
E - "..the emotional connection potential donors feel to a charity CAN affect the amount of money the charity raises in donations.."
Okay this addresses our inference exactly. The author uses (E), and believes it to conclude that "....therefore, charities can increase donations by giving donors the right to vote.."
The NA here, can be thought of as the belief the author has, thats unstated in the premises, that would A: confirm and strengthen their reasoning, and B: confirm their conclusion in this case.
ALSO if we negate (E):
"...the emotional connection potential donors feel to a charity CANNOT affect the amount of money the charity raises in donations..."
would this weaken the authors premises AND reasoning? if negated (E) were true, how the hell could the author come to their conclusion? It would seriously undermine the authors reasoning. It directly attacks the inference we made.
Lesson: The right answer (E) supported our inference and more importantly it supported the authors reasoning in arriving at their conclusion. The NA can be thought of as the belief the author has to support of their own conclusion, notice how similar it was to our inference? The NA's job is to support and strengthen the premises, and if you made an inference, its handy to have, because the NA will confirm the inference. The NA will not consider MORE than what is necessary, or beyond what the author considered.
The wrong answers in this question did not address the authors inference and conclusion, or considered something outside of what the author considered. (used modifiers to objects that the author did not consider like "atleast" and "some" donors)
We are looking for a sufficient assumption. FIRST lets find write our premises and conclusion so WE KNOW what rules to follow here.
Premise 1: "...If there is no meaningful connection, then there is no trust..."
NO meaningful connection--NO trust
Contrapositive: Trust--Meaningful connection
Premise 2: "...If we feel isolation, then there is no meaningful connection..."
Isolation--NO meaningful connection
Contrapositive: Meaningful connection--NO isolation
Conclusion: "...If you're happy, then you have trust..."
Authors conclusion: Happiness---Trust
How did the author get to this point from all of our premises?????
Lets put our premises together.
Trust--Meaningful connection--NO isolation
Now that we have this rule right here, lets go back to the authors conclusion.
Happiness--Trust
It looks like we can add this to our chain.
Happiness--trust--meaningful connection--NO isolation
What SA could we imagine applying here that would guarantee this entire chain?
A - "...No one who is feeling isolated can feel happy..."
This is saying, "...if you're feeling isolated, then you're not happy.."
Isolated--NOT happy
contrapositive: Happy--NOT isolated
does this reflect the rules that we have? Yes. If (A) were the SA, it would have to guarantee the authors conclusion. (A) captures the entire picture here from start to finish, which is what a sufficient assumption should do. This is our answer.
B - This doesn't address the isolation component of the chain we found. This is incomplete, therefore its not a "the" sufficient assumption we need to guarantee the authors conclusion. eliminate.
C - This mistakes the "necessary condition for happiness" (NO isolation) for the "sufficient condition for happiness" (trust from the premises, or happiness itself from the conclusion).
Answer (C): NO isolation--Trust
We don't know the outcome if someone is not feeling isolation in their lives. We ONLY know that if you have the ability to trust, then you will not feel isolated. And conversely, if you're feeling isolated, then you don't have the ability to trust.
this is it. this is all we know. eliminate.
D - "atleast some" we can already eliminate this just off the modifier thats used here. First: we're looking for an SA, which more often than usual, has to account for a lot of things in order to guarantee a conclusion and (D) already constrains our pool of data by a large margin. Second: Did the author use any modifiers to give us an idea of the quantity of people being considered here? No.
Also this is logically inconsistent, This commits the same error as (C).
E - This is incomplete, it doesn't explain our entire chain. also "at least one other human being", this modifier disqualifies this answer off the bat. we are looking for a sufficient assumption here, (E) is way too weak to guarantee the authors conclusion.
Lesson: The right answer (A) portrayed the entire relationship between the authors premises, the conclusion and the inference the author made. It guaranteed the entire argument. The wrong answers, either logically invalidated the authors premises, thereby not guaranteeing the argument, or were too weak, in that, they used modifiers in the form of (atleast, some) to describe a quantity of people being considered in the principle. The right answer to a SA question is a principle that has to include the same amount of people or more than what the author considered, to be a sufficient assumption.
We are finding the most strongly supported. Let's find the conclusion, the premises, and what the conclusion DEPENDS on for its survival.
Premise 1: "..as part of a new trend in the writing of history, an emphasis of historical events has replaced the previous emphasis on overarching historical trends..."
Premise 2: "....The result is that the "latter" (overarching trends) are often overlooked..."
Conclusion: "...Therefore, the parallels that may exist between historical trends and current trends are also overlooked, which lessens our ability to learn from history..."
how did the author get to this point? what inference did they make?
"The parallels that may exist between "trends in history" (overarching historical trends being overlooked) and historical and current trends in general, lessens our ability to learn from history."
now that we have an inference, lets look at an answer which is strongly supported by this statement and the premises.
A - Does the author discuss what happens IF we DO study the details of historical events? The author discusses what happens when new interpretations are emphasized over older interpretations, "they" (older interpretations) are often overlooked. AND these parallels exist in general trends, which lessens our ability to learn from history. Eliminate.
B - We are not given any information on how to discern overarching historical trends. This is a wild goose chase answer. this is meant to waste your time.
C - We don't know the conditions for being able to learn history. we only know what the results are from these general trends that have parallels with history. and thats it.
D - "...a "change in emphasis in the interpretation of history" (overarching historical trends being overlooked) has lessened our ability to learn from history..."
This explains the authors reasoning and the inference made when in arriving at their conclusion. These "parallels" (overarching historical trends being overlooked) that may exist between historical and current trends, are also overlooked, which lessens our ability to learn from history.
This "change" (overarching historical trends being overlooked due to emphasis on newer interpretation, and its possible parallels with general trends) IS lessening our ability to learn from history. This is our answer.
E - Did the author convey to us what we should do, given the information? The author only claimed that "the current situation lessens our ability to learn from history." How could we then assume we ought to do? we cannot. we cannot speculate. eliminate.
Lesson: The correct answer (D) displayed the inference made by the author to arrive at their conclusion, given the premises. The wrong answers in this case, either displayed statements we could not possible know--given the information--or forced us to speculate.
An answer that forces you to speculate beyond what can be inferred, when the question is requiring you to pick an answer that is most supported by the passage, cannot be the correct answer. We are abiding strictly by the passage, and what the question has defined for us what the right answer will be.
The right answer will be directly relevant to the authors support, the premises and the inferential relationship between those two things. The inference is the unstated principle the author draws from their premises TO arrive at their conclusion.
The author believes if this "effect" (OA trends being overlooked), if it exist between general trends, THIS will lessen the ability to learn from history. The author needs to believe this in order to arrive at their conclusion.
We are looking for an answer that strengthens. Let's find the conclusion, the premises that offer support, and what the conclusion DEPENDS ON to be as effective as possible. This dependence will give us a clue what would be the most effective strengthen answer.
Premise 1: "...Tent caterpillies mark potential food routes with chemical traces called pheromones..."
Premise 2: "...Routes from food sources to the nest are marked heavily..."
Conclusion: "....therefore, tent caterpillobos are communal foragers who convey information to members of their family..."
What's the authors inference in arriving at their conclusion?
"...Since"tent" caterpillars mark food routes from their nest with pheromones to aid their family, they are communal foragers..."
Okay now that we have our inference, lets look for an answer that strengthens this inference.
A - "...a hungry "tent" caterpillar is more likely to follow heavily marked routes than lightly marked routes....".
Notice the inclusion of "tent" to describe the behavior of the species of caterpillar. If (A) were true, that means that everytent caterpillar that is a member of the tent caterpillar tribe IS more likely to follow "heavily marked routes" (tent caterpillar routes to nest) than lightly marked ones...".
This probability makes the authors conclusion highly probable as being true. this is our answer.
B - Would this affect the claim that tent caterpillars are communal foragers? Do we know of a situation where the "presence" of pheromones differs from concentration? and if this affects the ability of tent caterpillars when they forage for food? this is is wild goose chase answer choice. The LSAT writers use these to waste your time.
C - "sometimes" (C) suggest that the tent caterpillars are uncompromising little cuties, but other than that, does it support the authors conclusion further than where it currently stands? The author needs a statement that supports the communal forager conclusion, not "what makes a tent baby cute af?" eliminate.
D - "...pheromones left by tent caterpillars are "different" than pheromones by other animals..." This suggests that tent caterpillars can detect their own pheromones from pheromones of other animals. Does this support that their communal foragers exactly? More than (A)? No. they could just have exceptional pheromone discriminating behavior. Does that make them communal foragers?
Remember our premises, and what the author used to make their case.
"...Since"tent" caterpillars mark food routes from their nest with pheromones to aid their family, they are communal foragers..."
Does (D) help? slightly, but it still leaves the gigantic question mark, what about the caterpillars ability to find food for members of their own? (D) does NOT help in this way.
This is like when someone, when trying to justify their talent at something, they say, "I'm built different." how does this give us any insight into how you're able to make a fire ass margarita? We have no comparisons to judge from. This gives me nothing you lil dummy baby. Maybe if (D) specified that these other animals were also communal foragers, (D) would more supportive. But (A) makes the strongest impact.
E - This would suggest that tent caterpillars are communal foragers, BUT NOT with their own members. which would undermine the authors conclusion that tent caterpillarsthemselves are communal foragers with members of their own family. eliminate.
Lesson: Determine the conclusion, the premises, and what the CONCLUSION DEPENDS ON for its effectiveness. In this case the author relied on heavily laid pheromones on routes from food sources to the nest AS EVIDENCE to support the conclusion that tent caterpillars are communal foragers. (A) support this inference, which made the authors conclusion highly probable.
We are finding a principle that helps justify the reasoning the authors argument. first lets find the conclusion, the premises, and what the conclusion DEPENDS ON for survival. this should give us a clue on what inference the author used as their principle on coming to their conclusion.
Premise 1: "...in competitive sports, people with major stress are more likely to be injured than other people..."
Premise 2: "...Risking serious injury is unwise..."
Conclusion: "...therefore, sports in general should not be used by people with major stress..."
how does the author arrive here? what inference did they make from Premise 2 to the conclusion?
"Since risking injury in competitive sports is unwise for people with mental stress, these people shouldn't play any sports."
Okay now that we have our inference, lets look at the answers.
A - "...if people recently under stress should avoid a "subset of activities of a certain type" (competitive sports), they should avoid "ALL activities of that type" (sports).
This is our inference the author made in arriving at their conclusion. and it confirms their conclusion. Since we're looking for a "principle" we are looking for something that is sufficient in guaranteeing the authors conclusion.
B - Would this explain the authors reasoning at all? Does it atleast help the author in arriving at their conclusion??? this principle would apply if the author had argued "activities" in general as effective methods for coping with stress. This is thematically different to what the passage communicates. eliminate.
C - Does the author argue ON BEHALF of people who don't experience major stress? No, they actually argue on behalf of people who are stressed the eff out. They argue that people with stress should not play sports in general. ALSO would this principle atleast help the authors reasoning???? No. eliminate.
D - This is contrary to what the author is arguing. Author determines that people with major stress are at higher risk of injuring themselves, that this is unwise, and concludes from this that these people should not play sports in general. eliminate.
E - Do we know about "people with a history of sports injuries"? No. we ONLY know about people with major stress compared to people without. that they are at higher risk of injuring themselves, its unwise to injure yourself, and they should not play any sports at all.
Lesson: Find the conclusion, the premises and what the authors conclusion depends on. This answer is requiring us to find the inference the author drew from the premises to arrive at their conclusion. In this case, the author assumes that "people with major stress should avoid all sports in general, since risking injury is unwise." (A) demonstrates this principle as an abstract. The inference can be helpful for finding the gaps the author assumes (SA) to guarantee their conclusion.
We are looking for the flaw, lets find the premises and conclusion.
Premise: "...currently, Wilson appliances make up only 25 % of such sales (hair dryers sold nationwide)..."
Premise: "...because of this decline (50% to 25%), and because of a 5-year consistent price of these hair dryers..."
Conclusion: "...the company's net income from sales of the product must be only half of what it was 5 years ago..."
What is the author assuming here?
25% reduction in market share= 1/2 reduction in total company profit from hair dryer.
A - this is what the author does:
"...the companys net income from sales of the product must be only half of what it was 5 years ago..."
And the author is basing this conclusion on information having to do with market share reduction. the company could have a reduced market share in hair dryers for many reason.
The fact is, the author cannot assume a total reduction in total company profit for hair dryers, because of the company's reducing presence in the market for hair dryers.
B - the authors reasoning does not depend on this. it depends on the market share of Wilson's
C - irrelevant. The main premise of the authors argument is information on the market share of Wilsons' while concluding information on the company's net profit:
Market share of company's product does not equal company profit of that product
D - This authors faulty reasoning does not depend on this.
E - just like (D), the authors reasoning does not depend on this. it depends on the market share of Wilsons' and then mistaking market share for overall company profit.
Lesson: Market share of one product that a company sells cannot provide a picture of overall company profit for that product, what if more companies entered the industry, and diluted the market sharing pool?
Imagine someone (Bobby) selling candy in the cafeteria, at first they're the only kid selling, which means their market share is 100%. but then, 4 other kids also started selling candy five days later. This means Bobby now shares 20% of the market. thats an 80% reduction in market share. From this, can we conclude that Bobby's profit dropped 80%? No, bobby could still be selling his candy at the same price, and still have popularity with his consumers (demand).