Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 15
November 17, 2013Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 14
November 17, 2013Professor: The most important function of epic poetry is to transmit the values by which a group of people is to live. This transmission is accomplished not by an explicit discussion of those values, but rather by their embodiment in heroic figures, who are presented as role models. Imitating those role models gives meaning and direction to the lives of those who hear the poems.
Summary
Epic poetry’s most important function is the transmission of the values by which a group of people is to live.
In epic poetry, values are not transmitted by explicit discussion.
In epic poetry, values are transmitted by their embodiment in heroic figures, who are presented as role models.
If people imitate the role models in epic poems, such people gain meaning and direction in their lives.
Notable Valid Inferences
Epic poetry accomplishes its most important function by embodying values in heroic figures, who are presented as role models.
A
An important function of poetry is to give meaning and direction to the lives of those who hear or read it.
Could be false. The stimulus only discusses one important function of poetry: the transmission of values. This might lead to people gaining life meaning and direction if they do decide to imitate the characters, but that’s not the explicit function as the stimulus describes it.
B
Epic poems accomplish their most important function by presenting heroic figures as role models.
Must be true. The stimulus explicitly states that the most important function of epic poems is to transmit values, and that the poems do so by presenting heroic figures as role models.
C
When values are represented in poetry, they are rarely if ever set forth explicitly.
Could be false. We know that epic poems do not transmit values via explicit discussion, but it’s possible that other kinds of poems do!
D
For many groups of people, heroic figures serve as role models embodying the values by which those people are to live.
Could be false. The stimulus does not say that many groups of people view heroic figures as role models; rather, it says that if a person does see a heroic figure as a role model and imitates that figure, that person could gain meaning and direction in their life.
E
Only epic poetry presents heroic figures as role models that, if imitated, give meaning and direction to the lives of those who hear it.
Could be false. The stimulus only discusses epic poetry. It does not claim that other kinds of poetry or art do not utilize the same techniques described here.
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 13
November 17, 2013Consultant: The dramatic improvements in productivity achieved during the Industrial Revolution resulted in large part from standardization of processes and procedures coupled with centralization of planning and decision making. Yet, in recent years, many already productive companies have further improved their productivity by giving individual employees greater influence in decision making and in how they do their work.
"Surprising" Phenomenon
How have many already productive companies further improved their productivity by implementing less centralized planning and decisionmaking, even though more centralization has been known to lead to huge increases in productivity?
Objective
The correct answer should suggest a difference between the already productive companies and the average company that could explain why the already productive companies can increase their productivity more through less centralization.
A
Most companies still try to improve productivity mainly through greater standardization and centralization of decision making.
What most companies do doesn’t explain why the already productive companies we’re concerned with in the stimulus can increase productivity through less centralization.
B
Increased productivity is not the only benefit of giving individual employees greater control over their work; job satisfaction increases as well.
This might provide another reason companies may want less centralization, but doesn’t help explain how companies can become more productive through les centralization.
C
Most of the increases in industrial productivity that have occurred in recent years have been due to the introduction of advanced technology like industrial robots.
Even if most increase in productivity has occurred through technology, we still know some companies have increased productivity through less centralization. This answer doesn’t explain how this happened.
D
The innovations of the Industrial Revolution are only now being applied in those companies in which individual employees have traditionally been entirely in control of how they do their work.
This answer tells us what’s happening in companies in which individual employees already have complete individual control. This doesn’t relate to the already productive companies we’re concerned with in the stimulus, which are giving their employees more and more control.
E
Increases in productivity in highly productive companies depend on management’s broad application of innovative ideas solicited from individual employees about their work.
Once a company is already highly productive, further productivity comes from individual employees’ ideas. This could be why less centralization (and greater autonomy for employees) is how already productive companies become more productive.
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 12
November 17, 2013
A
Population growth trends are notoriously hard to predict with reasonable accuracy.
B
The amount of fresh water available to meet the needs of Earth’s population varies significantly from region to region.
C
Not all of Earth’s population will adopt water conservation methods in the near future.
D
If Earth’s population continues to increase, it will eventually outstrip all available resources.
E
The percentage of fresh water used for agriculture is likely to grow more quickly than is the percentage used for industry.
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 11
November 17, 2013A science class stored one selection of various fruits at 30 degrees Celsius, a similar selection in similar conditions at 20 degrees, and another similar selection in similar conditions at 10 degrees. Because the fruits stored at 20 degrees stayed fresh longer than those stored at 30 degrees, and those stored at 10 degrees stayed fresh longest, the class concluded that the cooler the temperature at which these varieties of fruits are stored, the longer they will stay fresh.
Summarize Argument
The class concludes that the colder the storage conditions for these fruits, the longer they will stay fresh. They support this with an experiment in which similar fruits were stored at 30, 20, and 10 degrees in similar conditions. The fruits at 20 degrees lasted longer than those at 30 degrees, and the ones at 10 degrees stayed fresh the longest.
Identify and Describe Flaw
The class’s reasoning is flawed because they draw a broad conclusion based on a small range of temperatures (10-30 degrees). They assume that colder storage always keeps the fruits fresh for longer, ignoring the possibility that there could be temperatures that are too cold. In other words, just because the fruits lasted longer at 10 degrees than at 30 doesn’t mean they’ll last longer at 0 degrees.
A
generalized too readily from the fruits it tested to fruits it did not test
This is the cookie-cutter flaw of hasty generalization. The class doesn't make a generalization about fruits that they did not test. Instead, they draw a conclusion about “these varieties of fruits,” meaning the fruits that they did test.
B
ignored the effects of other factors such as humidity and sunlight on the rate of spoilage
The class doesn’t mention other factors, but it doesn’t need to because the experiment controlled for them. By keeping the other conditions similar for each selection of fruits, the class tested the effect of temperature.
C
too readily extrapolated from a narrow range of temperatures to the entire range of temperatures
The experiment showed that within the narrow range of 10-30 degrees, colder storage keeps the fruits fresh longer. They then apply this to all temperatures, assuming that colder storage always works, without considering that some temperatures might be too cold.
D
assumed without proof that its thermometer was reliable
The class never mentions a thermometer at all. Even if they did, we have no reason to believe that the thermometer might be unreliable. The flaw in the class’s argument has to do with how they apply their experiment’s findings, not with their thermometer.
E
neglected to offer any explanation for the results it discovered
The class concludes that colder storage helps the fruits last longer; they don't need to explain why. Even if they did explain why, this wouldn’t fix the fact that they apply their results too broadly.
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 10
November 17, 2013Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 07
November 17, 2013
A
Farmers engaged in very large-scale cattle production generally try to reduce the labor costs involved in the production and sale of beef.
B
The wholesale price per pound of beef is approximately ten times the wholesale price per pound of bread.
C
The labor and marketing costs in producing and selling bread represent most of its cost, but the cost of feeding cattle represents most of the cost of producing beef.
D
Only an insignificantly small proportion of the beef sold in retail markets is produced from cattle fed on grass rather than grain.
E
The vast majority of retail grocery outlets purchase the bread they sell from small independent bakers but purchase the meat they sell from large wholesale processing operations.
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 08
November 17, 2013Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 09
November 17, 2013(1) Environmentally responsible corporations do all they can to pollute less.
(2) The corporation’s new production methods pollute less than the old ones.
(3) No methods exist that produce no pollution at all.
A
takes for granted that production methods that do not produce pollution cannot be developed
B
fails to take into account the possibility that different causes can have similar effects
C
generalizes too hastily from the inapplicability of a specific criticism to the inapplicability of a class of criticisms
D
takes for granted that because the company has attempted to reduce the amount of pollution produced, they must have succeeded
E
ignores the possibility that there are currently production methods that would allow the corporation to produce less pollution than it does now
Sign up to star your favorites LSAT 140 - Section 2 - Question 02
November 17, 2013Depression is a serious problem for residents of nursing homes. However, a recent study has found that residents who developed personal bonds with pets had significantly lower rates of depression than did residents who did not develop personal bonds with pets.
Summary
Depression is a serious problem in nursing homes. However, a recent study found that residents who formed bonds with pets had much lower rates of depression than those who didn't.
Strongly Supported Conclusions
Encouraging nursing home residents to have pets could potentially help to lower the rate of depression in nursing homes.
Depression in nursing homes might in part stem from residents’ lack of companionship.
A
Nursing-home residents are more subject to depression than any other individuals.
Unsupported. The stimulus tells us that depression is a serious problem for residents of nursing homes. However, it does not compare rates of depression among nursing home residents to rates of depression among anyone else.
B
The best method for helping a nursing-home resident to overcome depression is to provide access to a pet.
Unsupported. Although forming bonds with pets significantly lowers rates of depression among nursing home residents, we do not know that this is the best way for residents to overcome depression.
C
High rates of depression among nursing-home residents may result at least in part from a lack of companionship.
Strongly supported. Residents who formed bonds with pets had much lower rates of depression than those who didn’t, and bonds with pets are a kind of companionship. So, rates of depression may result in part from a lack of companionship.
D
Animal companionship is essential for psychological well-being.
Unsupported. We do not know that animal companionship is essential for psychological well-being simply because animal companionship could help alleviate depression in some circumstances.
E
Allowing free access to pets in nursing homes would eliminate problems relating to depression.
Unsupported. Allowing free access to pets could alleviate rates of depression in nursing homes, but we have no way to know whether it would entirely eliminate all problems relating to depression.