False dichotomy
(FalseDich)
False dichotomy
(FalseDich)
Arguments that attempt to split the world up into two (or more) mutually exclusive, jointly exhaustive options, when in fact there may be additional available options, or the options given do not actually exclude one another.
Avg. 0.15 per section
Eliminating options
18%
41%
14%
23%
Avg. difficulty: 3.3
Key tactics
- Example of a dichotomy that's false because the options aren't jointly exhaustive (there's a secret third option): "You don't support our righteous cause; therefore, you are against our cause."
- Example of a dichotomy that's false because the options aren't mutually exclusive (you can choose both): "You are going to law school; therefore, you will not go to business school."
- LSAT arguments (and arguments in the legal world) often reason by eliminating options -- some successfully, some unsuccessfully. You should aspire to recognize this argument form, then think critically about whether the choices presented to you truly account for all the options, and about whether you must choose between those options rather than picking them both.
Answer choice tips
- Example answer choices that point to this flaw:
- assumes without warrant that a situation allows only two possibilities.
- does not take into account that there may be other ways to stop the decrease in profits.
- treats two things, neither one of which can plausibly be seen as excluding the other, as though they were mutually exclusive.
- fails to consider that innate dispositions and social conditioning could jointly affect the popularity of a type of music.
Alternate explanation
Analogy (AC)
Analogy (LR)
Argument part
Bad authority
Bad authority (AC)
Causal chain
Causal mechanism
Causal reasoning
Causal reasoning (AC)
Circular reasoning
Circular reasoning (AC)
Conditional reasoning
Confusing sufficiency and necessity
Confusing sufficiency and necessity (AC)
Correlation
Diagram?
Directionally wrong
Eliminating options
Equivocation
Equivocation (AC)
Evaluate
Except (LR)
Failed alternate explanation
False dichotomy
False dichotomy (AC)
Fighting the hypothetical
Fill in the blank
Flaw or descriptive weakening
Illusory inconsistency
Inference
Internal contradiction
Internal contradiction (AC)
Irrelevant corroboration
Kick it up
Lack of support v. false conclusion
Lack of support v. false conclusion (AC)
Link assumption
Link assumption (AC)
Main conclusion or main point
Math
Math (AC)
Mental state v. reality
Mental state v. reality (AC)
Method of reasoning or descriptive
Miscellaneous (LR)
Misdirected response
Misdirected response (AC)
Most strongly supported
Must be false
Must be true
Necessary assumption
Not a flaw
Parallel flawed method of reasoning
Parallel method of reasoning
Part v. whole
Part v. whole (AC)
Phenomenon-hypothesis (LR)
Plausibility
Point at issue: agree
Point at issue: disagree
Principle
PSA - find or complete the application
PSA - find the rule
Quantifier
Quantifier (AC)
Relative v. absolute
Relative v. absolute (AC)
Resolve reconcile or explain
Rule-application
Sampling
Sampling (AC)
Source attack
Source attack (AC)
Strengthen
Sufficient assumption
Time
Time (AC)
Unwarranted assumption
Value judgment
Value judgment (AC)
Weaken
Weighing factors
Weighing factors (AC)
Analogy (RC)
Application
Art
Author’s attitude
Author’s perspective
Comparative
Critique or debate
Describe approach
Describe organization
Describe relationship
Except (RC)
Humanities
Implied
Law
Logical continuation
Main point
Meaning in context (of word, phrase, or idea)
Miscellaneous (RC)
Other’s perspective
Phenomenon-hypothesis (RC)
Principle or generalization
Problem-analysis
Purpose in context (of word, phrase, or idea)
Purpose of paragraph
Purpose of passage
Science
Single position
Spotlight
Stated
Structure
WSE (RC)