http://classic.7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-33-section-3-question-19/
I see why B is the best answer, but not 100 pct why it's right. Raphaela doesn't address this point specifically other than her umbrella statement that no government should redistribute.
But As I'm writing this, I see that's the point. She makes a broad statement, and Edward makes a generalization.
Choice D, which I originally posted is too broad to address Edward's argument.
I'm going to review Disagree Questions.