I got this wrong because while I did see the author was appealing to authority, I thought it was reasonable to assume that if the author says what an authority figure says, then it can be said that the author would say that too.
Answer Choice E basically says that the Meteorologist did not evaluate the merit of example from the Statistician. I thought by citing experts who are saying that no single thing can cause climate the Meteorologist was evaluating the merit of the example from the Statistician. But then I thought about it some more and it occurred to me that you can't necessarily say the Meteorologist evaluated the merits of the example just because he cited experts who cite a general principle that speaks to the counterexample.
I know this is a rough evaluation of the question and answer choice, but what I wanted to get clarity on is what I concluded above:
If an author cites what someone else says without saying it themselves can that author be said to have said the same thing?
This question makes me think the answer is no, but I was hoping someone could verify that.
https://classic.7sage.com/lsat_explanations/lsat-21-section-2-question-25/